Welcome Guest
Sign In | Register

You have to totally remove the DoD from your analysis

Posted on: December 3, 2016 at 10:19:19 CT
ummmm MU
Posts:
44901
Member For:
13.45 yrs
Level:
User
M.O.B. Votes:
0
as the article has nothing to do with it.

Just focus on whether or not there are benefits on using heavy handed govt tactics to keep a production within your jurisdictional boundaries, even if that means higher production costs for the company.

That, alone, is economic lunacy.
Report Message

Please explain why this message is being reported.

REPLY

Handle:
Password:
Subject:

MESSAGE THREAD

A great article on the Carrier deal - ummmm MU - 12/3 09:42:22
     Just a massive amount of butthurt. - justwinbaby KC - 12/3 14:22:12
     It's a shortsighted deal - Ferg STL - 12/3 11:19:34
          Yeah, I don't think those numbers are correct - Sal KC - 12/3 12:11:04
               1100 workers staying out of 2400 - JG A - 12/3 13:19:29
                    2100 were moving, not "at risk". (nm) - 90Tiger MU - 12/3 15:31:55
                         2400 and from an American POV - JG A - 12/3 16:44:22
               it's an odd reaction, isn't it? (nm) - 90Tiger MU - 12/3 12:40:06
          Only Indiana made a tax deal, there aren't 330,000,000 - 90Tiger MU - 12/3 11:45:41
     Why did donald cut a deal with Carrier to move 600 jobs to - tigerdb MU - 12/3 10:50:32
          Because anecdotes (no matter that over half - JG A - 12/3 11:01:01
               Ah, so you think this is not only philosophically wrong but - 90Tiger MU - 12/3 11:17:23
                    With the exception of the workers in question and their - JG A - 12/3 12:34:05
                         how is that? (nm) - 90Tiger MU - 12/3 12:40:29
                              Well those workers keep their jobs - JG A - 12/3 12:41:58
                                   Yes, how does it hurt others elsewhere - other than - 90Tiger MU - 12/3 12:42:45
                                        higher prices - JG A - 12/3 13:04:41
                                             higher prices for what? carrier just saved 7 million in - 90Tiger MU - 12/3 14:22:21
                                                  air conditioners - JG A - 12/3 18:03:57
                    so you like the government dictating operational strategy - Ferg STL - 12/3 11:21:49
                         dictate? Carrier could have opted to move the position - 90Tiger MU - 12/3 11:46:20
                              They're moving 600; were never going to move 300 of those - tigerdb MU - 12/3 11:50:40
                                   what are you talking about? UTX planned to move 2100 - 90Tiger MU - 12/3 11:56:39
                                        trump "saved" 800 - claimed 1,100 Carrier jobs; - tigerdb MU - 12/3 12:18:44
                                             so you agree 800 jobs are staying. fine (nm) - 90Tiger MU - 12/3 12:38:43
          Probably only needed one photo op (nm) - ummmm MU - 12/3 10:51:42
     Yay, American jobs suck. nm. - MUTGR MU - 12/3 10:30:36
          Jobs should never be the focus. - ummmm MU - 12/3 10:32:31
               Jobs for the working class should absolutely be the focus - MUTGR MU - 12/3 11:07:47
               Yes with middle ages level productivity. Productivity is - TigerMatt STL - 12/3 10:57:23
     Myopic and simplistic opinion piece lacking facts and logic - Salty Dog MU - 12/3 10:12:50
          Republigistians don't really believe in the free market - JG A - 12/3 10:40:39
               RE: Republigistians don't really believe in the free market - Uncle Fester USMC - 12/3 11:23:26
               some don't - Ferg STL - 12/3 11:17:18
                    Some might - JG A - 12/3 12:42:44
          it certainly focuses only on one half of the "unseen" - 90Tiger MU - 12/3 10:24:37
     Trump cannot apply tariffs to Carrier - raskolnikov MU - 12/3 10:11:45
          Progressives who put corporate profits over American jobs. n - MUTGR MU - 12/3 10:31:48
          ^^ Been listening to the myopic simplicity and bias of NPR - Salty Dog MU - 12/3 10:17:38
               Haven't listened to NPR in a long while, that is just - raskolnikov MU - 12/3 10:26:30
                    the comparison to the auto bailout is funny. this isn't - 90Tiger MU - 12/3 11:55:35
                         Toro is the one who brought it up(nm) - raskolnikov MU - 12/3 12:33:18
          Well, at least, you are now learning the nature of govt. (nm) - ummmm MU - 12/3 10:17:25
     RE: A great article on the Carrier deal - 90Tiger MU - 12/3 10:10:43
          Everything about this story is speculative, but we should - ummmm MU - 12/3 10:15:32
               That's all well and good but considering the unseen in - 90Tiger MU - 12/3 10:16:55
                    You have to totally remove the DoD from your analysis - ummmm MU - 12/3 10:19:19
                         Removing the DoD is absurd, they are a business agent - 90Tiger MU - 12/3 10:22:06
                              If the exercise is to determine whether or not keeping - ummmm MU - 12/3 10:27:43
                                   is that the exercise? to determine where in the globe - 90Tiger MU - 12/3 11:15:34
                                        The exercise, from the article in my OP, is to determine - ummmm MU - 12/3 11:49:12
                                             is the facility operating at higher costs given the tax - 90Tiger MU - 12/3 12:05:50
     Lots of assumptions and what ifs in that article. - tiger4real MU - 12/3 09:46:35
          Here's what I think is probable. - Evenflow MU - 12/3 09:59:27
               "to threaten their livelihood"? you mean to ensure they - 90Tiger MU - 12/3 10:11:29
                    I realize you've become a big Trump Fan now but - Evenflow MU - 12/3 10:14:20
                         Sure, but isn't that a different conversation and issue - 90Tiger MU - 12/3 10:17:39
                              His 'angle' is the 600 dollar toilet seat, basically.(nm) - Evenflow MU - 12/3 10:26:15
               in other words, he got a deal done. - tiger4real MU - 12/3 10:07:53
                    I mean, if that's what you think government's role is, - Evenflow MU - 12/3 10:12:21
                         Yes I would. - tiger4real MU - 12/3 10:23:21
                              The Carrier deal is a threat. (nm) - Evenflow MU - 12/3 10:27:01
                                   to whom?nm - tiger4real MU - 12/3 10:29:07
                                        Any other company who tries to do what Trump - Evenflow MU - 12/3 10:30:24
                                             any other company doing business with the US? getting - 90Tiger MU - 12/3 11:22:01
                                             we'll see about that. I don't think so.nm - tiger4real MU - 12/3 10:34:10
                         govt is one of the players in this deal - the DoD buys - 90Tiger MU - 12/3 10:14:43
          True, and the author acknowledges that. (nm) - ummmm MU - 12/3 09:47:26
               Here's the thing, Mexico has already said they will adapt. - tiger4real MU - 12/3 10:01:30
                    See this is the problem with what Hayek called the "fatal - ummmm MU - 12/3 10:09:26
                         Here's the rub, Trump isn't operating in a free market vacuu - 90Tiger MU - 12/3 10:12:52
                              Exactly. US govt fiscal policy has been pathetic. - tiger4real MU - 12/3 10:19:10
                                   You're not defending the free market here, fyi - ummmm MU - 12/3 10:20:46
                                        im for a complete reversal in what govt has been doing the - tiger4real MU - 12/3 10:28:40
                                             If you are for a complete reversal, then support a broad - ummmm MU - 12/3 10:36:02
                                                  We aren't privy to all the details of this negotiation. - tiger4real MU - 12/3 10:41:53
                                                       The lowering of taxes is a step in the right direction - ummmm MU - 12/3 10:47:32
                                        You're not defending it either, ummmm. You're defending - 90Tiger MU - 12/3 10:23:43
                                             In pointing out that the govt should not interfere with - ummmm MU - 12/3 10:30:32
                                                  the govt is part of the business transaction here, ummmm - - 90Tiger MU - 12/3 11:16:31
                                                       That is the problem, of course. - ummmm MU - 12/3 11:50:08
                                                            You seem to be selecting only a few of those - 90Tiger MU - 12/3 11:57:52
                              Be that as it may, it doesn't undo underlying economic - ummmm MU - 12/3 10:16:41
                                   Who claims they do? Who knows they are wrong or right? - 90Tiger MU - 12/3 10:20:10
                                        Seeing that supporters of this Carrier deal are certain that - ummmm MU - 12/3 10:24:46
                                             Trump and Pence aren't acting on Carrier's behalf. they are - 90Tiger MU - 12/3 11:21:11
                                                  You are totally missing this one, 90 - ummmm MU - 12/3 11:52:44
                                                       last point - why do you call "lower prices for A/C units" - 90Tiger MU - 12/3 12:39:48
                                                       no, those are unseen also. you also are assuming - 90Tiger MU - 12/3 12:07:23




©2025 Fanboards L.L.C. — Our Privacy Policy   About Tigerboard