Welcome Guest
Sign In | Register

Here's the rub, Trump isn't operating in a free market vacuu

Posted on: December 3, 2016 at 10:12:52 CT
90Tiger STL
Posts:
163302
Member For:
23.36 yrs
Level:
User
M.O.B. Votes:
0
m. Carrier is subject to corporate tax rates, obamacare mandates and other factors that Mexico isn't dealing with.

this isn't a central plan, it's a reaction tactically to existing central plans.
Report Message

Please explain why this message is being reported.

REPLY

Handle:
Password:
Subject:

MESSAGE THREAD

A great article on the Carrier deal - ummmm MU - 12/3 09:42:22
     Just a massive amount of butthurt. - justwinbaby KC - 12/3 14:22:12
     It's a shortsighted deal - Ferg STL - 12/3 11:19:34
          Yeah, I don't think those numbers are correct - Sal KC - 12/3 12:11:04
               1100 workers staying out of 2400 - JG MU - 12/3 13:19:29
                    2100 were moving, not "at risk". (nm) - 90Tiger MU - 12/3 15:31:55
                         2400 and from an American POV - JG MU - 12/3 16:44:22
               it's an odd reaction, isn't it? (nm) - 90Tiger MU - 12/3 12:40:06
          Only Indiana made a tax deal, there aren't 330,000,000 - 90Tiger MU - 12/3 11:45:41
     Why did donald cut a deal with Carrier to move 600 jobs to - tigerdb MU - 12/3 10:50:32
          Because anecdotes (no matter that over half - JG MU - 12/3 11:01:01
               Ah, so you think this is not only philosophically wrong but - 90Tiger MU - 12/3 11:17:23
                    With the exception of the workers in question and their - JG MU - 12/3 12:34:05
                         how is that? (nm) - 90Tiger MU - 12/3 12:40:29
                              Well those workers keep their jobs - JG MU - 12/3 12:41:58
                                   Yes, how does it hurt others elsewhere - other than - 90Tiger MU - 12/3 12:42:45
                                        higher prices - JG MU - 12/3 13:04:41
                                             higher prices for what? carrier just saved 7 million in - 90Tiger MU - 12/3 14:22:21
                                                  air conditioners - JG MU - 12/3 18:03:57
                    so you like the government dictating operational strategy - Ferg STL - 12/3 11:21:49
                         dictate? Carrier could have opted to move the position - 90Tiger MU - 12/3 11:46:20
                              They're moving 600; were never going to move 300 of those - tigerdb MU - 12/3 11:50:40
                                   what are you talking about? UTX planned to move 2100 - 90Tiger MU - 12/3 11:56:39
                                        trump "saved" 800 - claimed 1,100 Carrier jobs; - tigerdb MU - 12/3 12:18:44
                                             so you agree 800 jobs are staying. fine (nm) - 90Tiger MU - 12/3 12:38:43
          Probably only needed one photo op (nm) - ummmm MU - 12/3 10:51:42
     Yay, American jobs suck. nm. - MUTGR MU - 12/3 10:30:36
          Jobs should never be the focus. - ummmm MU - 12/3 10:32:31
               Jobs for the working class should absolutely be the focus - MUTGR MU - 12/3 11:07:47
               Yes with middle ages level productivity. Productivity is - TigerMatt STL - 12/3 10:57:23
     Myopic and simplistic opinion piece lacking facts and logic - Salty Dog MU - 12/3 10:12:50
          Republigistians don't really believe in the free market - JG MU - 12/3 10:40:39
               RE: Republigistians don't really believe in the free market - Uncle Fester USMC - 12/3 11:23:26
               some don't - Ferg STL - 12/3 11:17:18
                    Some might - JG MU - 12/3 12:42:44
          it certainly focuses only on one half of the "unseen" - 90Tiger MU - 12/3 10:24:37
     Trump cannot apply tariffs to Carrier - raskolnikov MU - 12/3 10:11:45
          Progressives who put corporate profits over American jobs. n - MUTGR MU - 12/3 10:31:48
          ^^ Been listening to the myopic simplicity and bias of NPR - Salty Dog MU - 12/3 10:17:38
               Haven't listened to NPR in a long while, that is just - raskolnikov MU - 12/3 10:26:30
                    the comparison to the auto bailout is funny. this isn't - 90Tiger MU - 12/3 11:55:35
                         Toro is the one who brought it up(nm) - raskolnikov MU - 12/3 12:33:18
          Well, at least, you are now learning the nature of govt. (nm) - ummmm MU - 12/3 10:17:25
     RE: A great article on the Carrier deal - 90Tiger MU - 12/3 10:10:43
          Everything about this story is speculative, but we should - ummmm MU - 12/3 10:15:32
               That's all well and good but considering the unseen in - 90Tiger MU - 12/3 10:16:55
                    You have to totally remove the DoD from your analysis - ummmm MU - 12/3 10:19:19
                         Removing the DoD is absurd, they are a business agent - 90Tiger MU - 12/3 10:22:06
                              If the exercise is to determine whether or not keeping - ummmm MU - 12/3 10:27:43
                                   is that the exercise? to determine where in the globe - 90Tiger MU - 12/3 11:15:34
                                        The exercise, from the article in my OP, is to determine - ummmm MU - 12/3 11:49:12
                                             is the facility operating at higher costs given the tax - 90Tiger MU - 12/3 12:05:50
     Lots of assumptions and what ifs in that article. - tiger4real MU - 12/3 09:46:35
          Here's what I think is probable. - Evenflow MU - 12/3 09:59:27
               "to threaten their livelihood"? you mean to ensure they - 90Tiger MU - 12/3 10:11:29
                    I realize you've become a big Trump Fan now but - Evenflow MU - 12/3 10:14:20
                         Sure, but isn't that a different conversation and issue - 90Tiger MU - 12/3 10:17:39
                              His 'angle' is the 600 dollar toilet seat, basically.(nm) - Evenflow MU - 12/3 10:26:15
               in other words, he got a deal done. - tiger4real MU - 12/3 10:07:53
                    I mean, if that's what you think government's role is, - Evenflow MU - 12/3 10:12:21
                         Yes I would. - tiger4real MU - 12/3 10:23:21
                              The Carrier deal is a threat. (nm) - Evenflow MU - 12/3 10:27:01
                                   to whom?nm - tiger4real MU - 12/3 10:29:07
                                        Any other company who tries to do what Trump - Evenflow MU - 12/3 10:30:24
                                             any other company doing business with the US? getting - 90Tiger MU - 12/3 11:22:01
                                             we'll see about that. I don't think so.nm - tiger4real MU - 12/3 10:34:10
                         govt is one of the players in this deal - the DoD buys - 90Tiger MU - 12/3 10:14:43
          True, and the author acknowledges that. (nm) - ummmm MU - 12/3 09:47:26
               Here's the thing, Mexico has already said they will adapt. - tiger4real MU - 12/3 10:01:30
                    See this is the problem with what Hayek called the "fatal - ummmm MU - 12/3 10:09:26
                         Here's the rub, Trump isn't operating in a free market vacuu - 90Tiger MU - 12/3 10:12:52
                              Exactly. US govt fiscal policy has been pathetic. - tiger4real MU - 12/3 10:19:10
                                   You're not defending the free market here, fyi - ummmm MU - 12/3 10:20:46
                                        im for a complete reversal in what govt has been doing the - tiger4real MU - 12/3 10:28:40
                                             If you are for a complete reversal, then support a broad - ummmm MU - 12/3 10:36:02
                                                  We aren't privy to all the details of this negotiation. - tiger4real MU - 12/3 10:41:53
                                                       The lowering of taxes is a step in the right direction - ummmm MU - 12/3 10:47:32
                                        You're not defending it either, ummmm. You're defending - 90Tiger MU - 12/3 10:23:43
                                             In pointing out that the govt should not interfere with - ummmm MU - 12/3 10:30:32
                                                  the govt is part of the business transaction here, ummmm - - 90Tiger MU - 12/3 11:16:31
                                                       That is the problem, of course. - ummmm MU - 12/3 11:50:08
                                                            You seem to be selecting only a few of those - 90Tiger MU - 12/3 11:57:52
                              Be that as it may, it doesn't undo underlying economic - ummmm MU - 12/3 10:16:41
                                   Who claims they do? Who knows they are wrong or right? - 90Tiger MU - 12/3 10:20:10
                                        Seeing that supporters of this Carrier deal are certain that - ummmm MU - 12/3 10:24:46
                                             Trump and Pence aren't acting on Carrier's behalf. they are - 90Tiger MU - 12/3 11:21:11
                                                  You are totally missing this one, 90 - ummmm MU - 12/3 11:52:44
                                                       last point - why do you call "lower prices for A/C units" - 90Tiger MU - 12/3 12:39:48
                                                       no, those are unseen also. you also are assuming - 90Tiger MU - 12/3 12:07:23




©2025 Fanboards L.L.C. — Our Privacy Policy   About Tigerboard