Welcome Guest

At the 3 star level, yes

Posted on: June 27, 2019 at 11:44:17 CT

Eggs MU

Posts:

154043

Member For:

26.44 yrs

Level:

User

M.O.B. Votes:

doesn't take into account level of competition in HS, potential, and weighs too heavily on who is recruiting them.

That being said, 5 star talent sticks out and generally isn't debatable.

Please explain why this message is being reported.

REPLY

MESSAGE THREAD

Hungry 3 star players vs. prima donna 5 star plays. Which - LONGTIMETIGERFAN MU - 6/27 07:34:01

Easy answer. 5* players. My experience all things equal - Ozland Tiger LSU - 6/27 16:01:08

Can field fun competitive teams with 3 stars, but - McKinneyTiger MU - 6/27 15:48:06

This kind of “psychology” is probably not valid - tigersailor MU - 6/27 13:59:10

RE: Hungry 3 star players vs. prima donna 5 star plays. Which - BobD9842 USA - 6/27 13:34:43

Alabama and Clemson get 5 star players. - ERB KC - 6/27 13:13:11

Agree. Let's do what Alabama and Clemson does. That type - MATO MU - 6/27 14:11:09

bingo (nm) - zounami MU - 6/27 14:37:43

It really matters for the top 10 schools - Hickeytime MU

- 6/27 13:26:21

the correlation goes the other way - phrejd MU

- 6/27 13:21:56

of course - a correlation goes both ways by definition.... - zounami MU - 6/27 13:52:45

they don't do independent evaluations. you are naive at best - phrejd MU

- 6/27 13:59:10

then how does Bama end up with 3-star and even 2-star - zounami MU - 6/27 14:03:18

here's how: - phrejd MU

- 6/27 17:30:19

remained a 3-star with offers from Michigan & Alabama?... - zounami MU - 6/27 18:33:17

and here's how: - phrejd MU

- 6/27 17:34:21

remained a 3-star with offers from Tennessee, Alabama, and - zounami MU - 6/27 18:33:51

and here's how: - phrejd MU

- 6/27 17:38:53

remained a 3-star?... if so, proves my point (nm) - zounami MU - 6/27 18:34:06

you are clearly not understanding this. but best of luck - phrejd MU

- 6/27 19:15:46

and here's how: - phrejd MU

- 6/27 17:50:06

LOL(nm) - ToTheFinishLine MU - 6/27 13:25:06

Southern Cal won the class rating championship in 2015 - phrejd MU

- 6/27 13:34:11

Really easy answer: QB was really young. The most - ToTheFinishLine MU - 6/27 13:50:18

so their ranking championship and 5 straight years of top 10 - phrejd MU

- 6/27 13:58:12

If the QB sucks, the rest of the team doesn't matter, does - ToTheFinishLine MU - 6/27 15:25:15

lol. their QB is a 5*, #4 rated player in the nation. you're - phrejd MU

- 6/27 17:43:24

good recruiting doesn't guarantee success on the field... - zounami MU - 6/27 14:01:58

really? **** i had no idea. thanks for that tidbit of info (nm) - phrejd MU

- 6/27 17:44:17

5 (and 4) star prospects... you need them to compete for - zounami MU - 6/27 11:52:31

the ratings are bunk - FootballRefugee MU

- 6/27 11:36:42

At the 3 star level, yes - Eggs KC - 6/27 11:44:17

there are plenty of 5-star busts, too - FootballRefugee MU

- 6/27 11:56:36

no, the vast majority of 5 stars are can't-miss prospects... - zounami MU - 6/27 12:03:22

We've seen the ceiling of hungry 3 star players - Eggs KC - 6/27 11:30:24

Like SMU pony'd up for the Pony Express?(nm) - jake_mu MU - 6/27 14:34:14

Tom Osborne and Bob Devaney had to do things - FootballRefugee MU

- 6/27 11:57:20

RE: Tom Osborne and Bob Devaney had to do things - BobD9842 USA - 6/27 13:37:15

...the battle with the police and the courts - FootballRefugee MU

- 6/27 14:28:01

I would love to see us load up on almost 4 & 4 star players - MU-TULSA MU - 6/27 10:37:05

I think you mean pre-Madonna players. Nm - BandG MU - 6/27 09:57:09

Seems they would be quite old(nm) - meatiger MU - 6/27 10:51:46

in a few years pre-LadyGaga will be too old (nm) - zounami MU - 6/27 11:59:02

5 star - Cosmo MU

- 6/27 09:48:35

5 stars, obviously. (nm) - Newcatbirdseat MU - 6/27 09:42:22

✔️ ✔️ - Spartus MWSC - 6/27 11:56:19

Give me the better players...since those are the teams that - TheWildcat STL - 6/27 09:38:42

I think that's why since the program was stabilized - Genco98 MU - 6/27 08:21:16

We did recruit better under GP, usually, than we have lately - Gamagrass MU - 6/27 11:25:04

We had good teams every year under GP except - RayPecTiger18 MU - 6/27 10:02:07

Pinkel had the right guys in the right spots, just no depth(nm) - ToTheFinishLine MU - 6/27 10:16:44

Sure, but talent will usually win out. And a - GA Tiger MU - 6/27 08:13:20

RE: Hungry 3 star players vs. prima donna 5 star plays. Which - Knopf MU - 6/27 08:04:33

you want the most talented guys you can get - Jeff85 MU - 6/27 07:38:57

Yes. That’s why teams in the playoff - wu-tangtiger MU - 6/27 08:12:04

You get the best players you can get while doing 2 things - alwaysright MU - 6/27 08:59:49

#2 is the key - BigDave STL - 6/27 09:29:49