Welcome Guest

Very cool, thanx for sharing that. To JG's always wise and

Posted on: August 22, 2018 at 12:43:38 CT
hokie VT
Posts:
67482
Member For:
9.52 yrs
Level:
User
M.O.B. Votes:
0
always honest post above, the political causes of the war should be separated from the causes that the soldiers believed in.

The preservation of the union was paramount to many yankees. Slavery was secondary or tertiary in the list of reasons to fight and die.
The right to self governance and states' rights were in the forefront of many of the confederate soldiers' thoughts and deeds. They saw themselves as not unlike the patriots of 1776, fighting a governing body that did not consider their interests and needs. Again slavery was not the prevailing factor to many of the hoi polloi of the time.

It is fair in my opinion to say that slavery was the main reason especially from the political standpoint, for the war. But it is far from the only reason.
Report Message

Please explain why this message is being reported.

REPLY

Handle:
Password:
Subject:

MESSAGE THREAD

Serious question re teaching of history. - hokie VT - 8/22 11:38:37
     All I know is, there wouldn't be any race problems today if - GA Tiger MU - 8/22 13:41:08
     if no slaves would have been brought here - DC Jayhawk KU - 8/22 12:43:05
          Interesting point. It is conflicted with the historical - hokie VT - 8/22 12:46:29
     The Civil War is almost entirely about slavery - JG A - 8/22 12:32:56
          Your first comment is correct. Your next one is not. - GA Tiger MU - 8/22 13:45:09
     RE: Serious question re teaching of history. - MUTGR MU - 8/22 12:31:08
          Very cool, thanx for sharing that. To JG's always wise and - hokie VT - 8/22 12:43:38
               RE: Very cool, thanx for sharing that. To JG's always wise and - MUTGR MU - 8/22 19:22:17
     You might want to check out some history books with an - JeffB MU - 8/22 12:09:46
          Cool, thanx. nm - hokie VT - 8/22 12:17:54
               Older books, many hopefully still in libraries, could also - JeffB MU - 8/22 12:23:15
     Curious, did you ask your professor any of these questions? - Mo Texan MU - 8/22 12:03:53
     Slavery is indeed horrible history. The problem is using it - RHAYWORTH MU - 8/22 12:00:32
     I would say that the biggest impact - Mormad MU - 8/22 11:57:57
          Good points all. But what if slavery hadn't existed? Would - hokie VT - 8/22 12:02:18
               There certainly would have been trade - Mormad MU - 8/22 12:11:36
                    Would it have been that much different economically? - DHighlander NWMSU - 8/22 12:26:48
                         Slavery was hugely profitable for slave traders and for - hokie VT - 8/22 12:49:15
     It's all pretty much a government problem. - Newcatbirdseat MU - 8/22 11:39:41
          Thanx for playing. Now run along.... nm - hokie VT - 8/22 11:55:34




©2025 Fanboards L.L.C. — Our Privacy Policy   About Tigerboard