Welcome Guest
Sign In | Register

I have read UMMs arguement and have responded to it several

Posted on: August 9, 2017 at 16:30:48 CT
tman MU
Posts:
35160
Member For:
21.13 yrs
Level:
User
M.O.B. Votes:
0
Times previously in one form or fashion. You want it again. Here it is:

I do not believe Art 1 Section 8 or the 14th amendment explicitly grants the Federal Government authority over immigration. As I have stated there is an argument to be made here and the courts have determined the Federal Government has that authority. However, the words naturalization and immigration are not synanomous,and they were clearly different back at the time the Constitution was written. Hence to me it is a state issue and not Federal.

The powers of the Federal Government were intended to be extremely limited, this is another example were the courts have expanded their authority

I will wait for your counter argument
Report Message

Please explain why this message is being reported.

REPLY

Handle:
Password:
Subject:

MESSAGE THREAD

Law of Nations: Immigration in US Constitution. - Alferd Packer MU - 8/9 14:50:28
     Also: - ummmm MU - 8/9 15:25:07
     Sorry, AP, but no. - pickle MU - 8/9 15:07:17
          I knew somebody would claim that without checking - Alferd Packer MU - 8/9 15:40:13
               That doesn't refute my post - pickle MU - 8/9 15:45:42
                    You think you found a loophole but you didn't. - Alferd Packer MU - 8/9 16:03:00
                         No. Congress is not the Sovereign - pickle MU - 8/9 16:09:12
                              The government is the sovereign according to deV. - Alferd Packer MU - 8/9 16:25:32
                                   Sorry, but no (nm) - pickle MU - 8/9 16:50:09
                                        So, explain what this means if not what it says. - Alferd Packer MU - 8/9 20:27:18
                    opps (nm) - 90Tiger MU - 8/9 15:54:25
     What happened to this angle? - ummmm MU - 8/9 14:55:00
          I have said it is a state power, but this is an interesting - tman KC - 8/9 15:32:49
               That's some odd logic - pickle MU - 8/9 15:38:09
                    Wut. I will type slow - tman KC - 8/9 15:50:44
                         This doesn't address my post at all (nm) - pickle MU - 8/9 15:52:40
          RE: What happened to this angle? - 90Tiger MU - 8/9 15:02:57
          Who cares? - Alferd Packer MU - 8/9 15:00:25
               I suppose I don't understand how the clause that - ummmm MU - 8/9 15:08:00
               Awesome (nm) - pickle MU - 8/9 15:01:01
                    Oh good, the argument has been decided forever! (nm) - tigerspy MU - 8/9 15:01:36
                         This is funny(nm) - tman KC - 8/9 15:16:42
                              it should be educational for you, but I doubt you'll take - 90Tiger MU - 8/9 15:26:57
                                   I will put my constitutional education up against yours any - tman KC - 8/9 15:33:54
                                        I'm going to grant you the superior education and argue - 90Tiger MU - 8/9 15:55:01
                                             You are entitled to do so, but you might actually - tman KC - 8/9 15:56:50
                                                  I'm going to claim being correct since you obviously didn - 90Tiger MU - 8/9 16:06:56
                                                       I have read UMMs arguement and have responded to it several - tman KC - 8/9 16:30:48
                                                            so you agree the courts ruled incorrectly, good. I'm - 90Tiger MU - 8/9 19:02:32
                                                            The courts have mostly relied on it being an implied - ummmm MU - 8/9 17:26:56
                                                                 yup. (nm) - 90Tiger MU - 8/9 19:03:02
                                                       His education and knowledge are so great - pickle MU - 8/9 16:11:18
                                                            He, like AP, is apparently following the US gov'ts path o - 90Tiger MU - 8/9 16:20:31
                                                                 You are worse then the libs on this board - tman KC - 8/9 16:32:12
                                                  Irony (nm) - pickle MU - 8/9 16:06:15
                                        Go for it (nm) - pickle MU - 8/9 15:38:35
                                             Are you and 90 the same person? - tman KC - 8/9 15:53:44
                                                  Oh, I see - pickle MU - 8/9 16:02:05
                                                       Good everyone should. (nm) - tman KC - 8/9 16:36:07
                                                            Can't say I agree - pickle MU - 8/9 16:49:19
                                                  Is it a premise here that those who instructed you were - 90Tiger MU - 8/9 15:57:06
                                                       You started the educational piece not me. - tman KC - 8/9 16:35:20
     Junior high level argument incoming in 3, 2, 1... (nm) - tigerspy MU - 8/9 14:52:07
          psst - your post appeared when your count went to 0 (nm) - 90Tiger MU - 8/9 15:03:38
               Hmm... that was more grade school level. (nm) - tigerspy MU - 8/9 15:07:25
                    You just made his day - JG MU - 8/9 15:22:01




©2024 Fanboards L.L.C. — Our Privacy Policy   About Tigerboard