Welcome
Guest
Sign In
|
Register
BASKETBALL
FOOTBALL
ALL SPORTS
THE SHACK
TICKETS
POKER
POLITICS
WALL ST.
HELP / TESTING
ABOUT US
no
Posted on: January 4, 2017 at 12:47:50 CT
SwampTiger
MU
Posts:
56550
Member For:
26.03 yrs
Level:
User
M.O.B. Votes:
0
take away the getting caught part, still no
Please explain why this message is being reported.
Reason For Report:
REPLY
Handle:
Password:
Subject:
MESSAGE THREAD
Some weird hypotheticals: Recall the argument about
-
hokie
VT
-
1/4 12:40:38
You kill Hilter. Goebbels or Himmler rises to power.
-
TigerMatt
STL
-
1/4 15:23:16
Why do you have to kill anyone? Buy some of his art
-
TigerMatt
STL
-
1/4 15:03:01
You could make a movie about that....
-
Spanky
KU
-
1/4 14:15:31
I wouldn't do it, period, in any of those cases (nm)
-
90Tiger
MU
-
1/4 13:10:53
would you, knowing what he would do in the 30s
-
Mizzou Lou
KC
-
1/4 13:33:15
so now you've changed the scenario that i'm in active combat
-
90Tiger
MU
-
1/4 13:44:57
That's what makes it hypothetical. You accept the premise
-
hokie
VT
-
1/4 13:59:18
Hokie - if I eliminate a man before he commits some future
-
90Tiger
MU
-
1/4 14:09:04
Because....? And I appreciate your answer, I find
-
hokie
VT
-
1/4 13:19:45
Here's a moral hypothetical
-
pickle
MU
-
1/4 13:23:58
Depends on the law. Speeding no way
-
GODZILLA
MU
-
1/4 13:41:13
You've just included yourself in the premeditated
-
ummmm
MU
-
1/4 14:06:39
This is so silly. Dont want to be put to death dont
-
GODZILLA
MU
-
1/4 14:15:46
Do you not realize that you are calling for a mass murder
-
ummmm
MU
-
1/4 14:18:22
Do you consider every judge that has given
-
GODZILLA
MU
-
1/4 14:23:01
Complicitly, yes
-
ummmm
MU
-
1/4 14:34:05
All sorts of groups do that
-
Mormad
MU
-
1/4 13:27:25
If God's so certain
-
Mormad
MU
-
1/4 13:03:32
Question too tough? Nm
-
hokie
VT
-
1/4 13:10:36
No, it's not too tough.
-
Mormad
MU
-
1/4 13:18:29
THAT is a fascinating answer. We should drill down
-
hokie
VT
-
1/4 13:21:09
if God created him and man has self-determination, how
-
90Tiger
MU
-
1/4 13:48:00
The reason is
-
615Tiger
STL
-
1/4 13:09:54
I can not reconcile that with an all-powerful god who
-
GA Tiger
MU
-
1/4 14:36:59
Well, if it's a sin to kill him as a baby
-
Mormad
MU
-
1/4 13:15:05
Appreciate your answer. What of the present time
-
hokie
VT
-
1/4 13:14:48
"sacrifice"? his only son got to get to eternal bliss in th
-
90Tiger
MU
-
1/4 13:49:05
Hokie is implying the person has no choice (hitler must
-
90Tiger
MU
-
1/4 13:13:35
You KNOW what he will do. He did it. But you
-
hokie
VT
-
1/4 13:16:45
He didn't already do it if I have the option to prevent
-
90Tiger
MU
-
1/4 13:49:40
How about this hypothetical
-
615Tiger
STL
-
1/4 12:53:20
Not really much of a dilemma
-
pickle
MU
-
1/4 12:52:09
But, being from the future, you already know that Hitler
-
TigerJackSwartz
MU
-
1/4 13:04:07
You're incorrect
-
pickle
MU
-
1/4 13:21:21
They aren't potential to you. They've already happened
-
TigerJackSwartz
MU
-
1/4 13:28:46
if you're a future man, you can't exist in the past and if y
-
90Tiger
MU
-
1/4 14:12:31
Never mess with the past , man
-
JG
MU
-
1/4 12:48:35
What of the current time hypothetical? John doe
-
hokie
VT
-
1/4 13:09:13
silly, if i have the power to stop him, he wouldn't have
-
90Tiger
MU
-
1/4 13:15:28
You don't know if John Doe killed someone
-
JG
MU
-
1/4 13:15:25
no
-
SwampTiger
MU
-
1/4 12:47:50
It is clearly an act of self sacrifice. But you would
-
hokie
VT
-
1/4 13:06:57
It's murder
-
pickle
MU
-
1/4 13:22:34
RE: It is clearly an act of self sacrifice. But you would
-
SwampTiger
MU
-
1/4 13:15:42
No I would kidnap him and give to raskol to raise
-
Ragnar Danneskjold
MU
-
1/4 12:44:19
He might prefer
-
615Tiger
STL
-
1/4 12:55:25