Welcome Guest

"Fixing" the electoral college, part 1: outline

Posted on: November 10, 2016 at 11:40:00 CT
CulturedDan MU
Posts:
92444
Member For:
14.90 yrs
Level:
User
M.O.B. Votes:
0
With all of the complaints about the electoral college, some have said it needs to be tweaked.

One way to "fix" it is to make the allocated votes proportional to the statewide vote - much like how it's done in the primaries (at least in the non-rigged ones).

Another way is to allocate them by congressional district, plus the statewide winner getting the 2 extra votes each state receives for their senate seat.

There are pros and cons to each method (being that it would increase participation in non-battleground states as minority-view citizens will be more likely to vote if their vote actually meant something. It would also encourage supporting 3rd party candidates in some states), and to changing the system as well. As the data comes through, I'm going to crunch the data based off this election to see if a difference is made.

I'm going to start with a straight-proportional system. Results this afternoon.

If there are other proposals, let me know.
Report Message

Please explain why this message is being reported.

REPLY

Handle:
Password:
Subject:

MESSAGE THREAD

"Fixing" the electoral college, part 1: outline - dangertim MU - 11/10 11:40:00
     If its a proportional vote, what have you accomplished. - GA Tiger MU - 11/10 12:32:18
          i'm running the numbers, and you're right. - dangertim MU - 11/10 12:42:29
     RE: "Fixing" the electoral college, part 1: outline - MOCO SON MU - 11/10 11:47:40
          the electoral college was very successful for the Dems - dangertim MU - 11/10 11:54:36
               RE: the electoral college was very successful for the Dems - MOCO SON MU - 11/10 12:04:02
     Nope, candidate will then be in CA TX NY FL and that's - TigerFan92 MU - 11/10 11:45:03
          if they do that, then they are litterally fighting for 10 of - dangertim MU - 11/10 11:51:36
               RE: if they do that, then they are litterally fighting for 10 of - MOCO SON MU - 11/10 11:58:52
                    True. Any global change would require constitutional action - DHighlander KC - 11/10 12:18:42
                    where was I calling for change? - dangertim MU - 11/10 12:02:16
     It's a federal election, not a national election. - ummmm MU - 11/10 11:42:58
          Except that the federal government has a few powers that - DHighlander KC - 11/10 12:22:57
               My post directly addresses the electoral college debate - ummmm MU - 11/10 12:25:06
                    You may want to go back and look at the enumerated powers - DHighlander KC - 11/10 12:58:07
                         Oh my - pickle MU - 11/10 13:10:02
                         Whoa, I am thinking you need to go back - ummmm MU - 11/10 13:05:01
                              Lets try again with actual clauses. - DHighlander KC - 11/10 13:20:47
                                   When I say original intent of the Constitution, you - ummmm MU - 11/10 13:28:58
                                   Lol (nm) - pickle MU - 11/10 13:24:55
                              This guy is a teacher - pickle MU - 11/10 13:09:04
                                   As do you. I am amazed that you can actually read.(nm) - DHighlander KC - 11/10 13:21:19
                    Lol - pickle MU - 11/10 12:38:09
                         Pickle posting without actually adding anything to the - DHighlander KC - 11/10 13:02:15
          thank you for missing the point(nm) - dangertim MU - 11/10 11:43:33
               I think I addressed your point - ummmm MU - 11/10 12:07:35
               What was the point? (nm) - pickle MU - 11/10 11:50:28
                    the point wasn't about federalism vs stateism(nm) - dangertim MU - 11/10 11:55:04
                         What was the point? (nm) - pickle MU - 11/10 11:55:28
                              I don't want to play this game today. - dangertim MU - 11/10 11:58:44
                                   I'm not playing a game (nm) - pickle MU - 11/10 12:05:12




©2025 Fanboards L.L.C. — Our Privacy Policy   About Tigerboard