Welcome Guest

RE: No, it’s not that (nm)

Posted on: January 27, 2025 at 18:08:54 CT

sks MU

Posts:

176

Member For:

5.4 months

Level:

User

M.O.B. Votes:

Replacing income tax with a consumption tax would not be good. Very regressive. Shifts much of the tax burden from the rich to the poor and middle class.

Please explain why this message is being reported.

REPLY

MESSAGE THREAD

Don’t threaten me with a good time Bessent - Bosalphus KC - 1/27 17:44:25

So basically, tax cuts for the rich paid for by the poor and - SparkyStalcup MU - 1/27 17:50:23

How would the poor and middle class pay? - Wildcat KSU - 1/27 19:43:09

Have you read any of this thread? If so, it went way - SparkyStalcup MU - 1/27 21:11:44

Did you read what I replied to? - Wildcat KSU - 1/27 22:17:00

A consumption tax is only paid when you purchase a good or - tigertix MU - 1/27 18:57:59

RE: A consumption tax is only paid when you purchase a good or - sks MU - 1/27 19:30:40

Nope, they spend $50k / year just like the poor folk - Bosalphus KC - 1/27 19:05:58

No it would be a tax rate indiscriminate of income(nm) - El-ahrairah BAMA - 1/27 18:22:10

No, it isn't. The rate might be flat, but middle class and - SparkyStalcup MU - 1/27 18:39:08

It's really dumb to assume equal spending levels (nm) - Bosalphus KC - 1/27 18:44:52

And it's more dumb to think the rich and poor both spend - SparkyStalcup MU - 1/27 21:09:48

They can fix in two ways - El-ahrairah BAMA - 1/27 18:44:26

Can't really spend less if they want to live. Nm - SparkyStalcup MU - 1/27 21:10:33

That new iPhone and flat screen aren't going to buy - Bosalphus KC - 1/27 18:45:35

No, it’s not that (nm) - Bosalphus KC - 1/27 17:57:01

RE: No, it’s not that (nm) - sks MU - 1/27 18:08:54

People can control what they spend money on - Bosalphus KC - 1/27 18:11:17

People at lower incomes spend a higher percentage of - SparkyStalcup MU - 1/27 18:31:15

You both seem to think the poor can't control their - Bosalphus KC - 1/27 18:44:10

They can control to a small extent what they spend it - SparkyStalcup MU - 1/27 21:08:34

Should the money I spend on - haeffb MU - 1/27 18:59:29

income tax doesn't discriminate on what you spend your - 90Tiger STL - 1/27 19:44:05

It sure doesn’t. - haeffb MU - 1/27 19:50:21

Then donate more of your own money (nm) - Bosalphus KC - 1/27 20:01:15

Sure why not? (nm) - Bosalphus KC - 1/27 19:05:13

RE: You both seem to think the poor can't control their - sks MU - 1/27 18:53:57

RE: People at lower incomes spend a higher percentage of - sks MU - 1/27 18:36:21

Unfortunately it's basically only you and I that understand - SparkyStalcup MU - 1/27 18:40:33

No, this is where you’re wrong. - haeffb MU - 1/27 18:53:36

Says the posters who advocate - Bosalphus KC - 1/27 19:05:33

You don’t? (nm) - haeffb MU - 1/27 19:12:27

Of course not (nm) - Bosalphus KC - 1/27 19:17:14

Roads, schools, police, national defense - haeffb MU - 1/27 19:25:45

You seem lost in this thread - Bosalphus KC - 1/27 19:29:37

Oh, I see. You just prefer it taken from your wallet - haeffb MU - 1/27 19:44:48

RE: People can control what they spend money on - sks MU - 1/27 18:14:55

But everybody doesn’t spend the same amount of $$$ - Bosalphus KC - 1/27 18:20:40

RE: But everybody doesn’t spend the same amount of $$$ - sks MU - 1/27 18:27:08

They don't spend money at the same rate - Bosalphus KC - 1/27 18:48:41

RE: They don't spend money at the same rate - sks MU - 1/27 18:52:18

Of course I do - Bosalphus KC - 1/27 19:04:44

RE: Of course I do - sks MU - 1/27 19:35:32

And don't forget that state and local taxes are regressive - SparkyStalcup MU - 1/27 18:33:39