Welcome Guest
Sign In | Register

So the commerce clause applies even when I do not choose to

Posted on: February 27, 2017 at 10:00:08 CT
DHighlander NWMSU
Posts:
51159
Member For:
16.87 yrs
Level:
User
M.O.B. Votes:
0
buy a service?

I would agree that the commerce clause can be used to regulate existing health care plans, within reason. It cannot be used as a reason to force you into a system.

I know you are just being willfully obtuse here but i answered your comment anyway.
Report Message

Please explain why this message is being reported.

REPLY

Handle:
Password:
Subject:

MESSAGE THREAD

#Calexit: Cal considering single payer with Obamacare - MUTGR MU - 2/27 09:15:17
     Then we build the wall ....nm - tigertix MU - 2/27 09:24:26
     Just like states SHOULD have done in the 1st place! - Spanky KU - 2/27 09:18:38
          HC is an individual issue. (nm) - ummmm MU - 2/27 09:24:53
               In theory, it should be an individual issue. In reality, it - Spanky KU - 2/27 09:50:52
                    It's reality, not theory - pickle MU - 2/27 09:55:49
                    in reality it is an individual issue that government inserts - MizzouAstro MU - 2/27 09:55:18
                    In reality, it is still an individual issue. - ummmm MU - 2/27 09:53:32
                         The reality is, it is a Federal issue usurped from states - Spanky KU - 2/27 10:41:00
                              If we were to accept your position, then nothing would be - ummmm MU - 2/27 10:43:27
               States have the constitutional authority to interfere in - DHighlander KC - 2/27 09:33:45
                    Obamacare was not unconstitutional - pickle MU - 2/27 09:57:14
                         So the commerce clause applies even when I do not choose to - DHighlander KC - 2/27 10:00:08
                              Yes, it applies even if you do not choose to buy a service. - pickle MU - 2/27 10:07:25
                                   It has been ruled constitutional, that does not make it so. - DHighlander KC - 2/27 10:23:28
                                        First of all, it's constitutional based on the Constitution - pickle MU - 2/27 11:20:52
                                             So you are claim that my refusal to not buy a product is - DHighlander KC - 2/27 11:28:04
                                                  I don't by DirectTV - pickle MU - 2/27 11:37:05
                                                       So congress can require that you subscribe? Commerce - DHighlander KC - 2/27 11:40:11
                                                            Yes, of course they can. They are regulating commerce - pickle MU - 2/27 11:44:29
                                                  Pickle was being facetious, you know. (nm) - ummmm MU - 2/27 11:36:12
                                        First of all, it was 3/5ths. Second of all, the Constitution - ummmm MU - 2/27 10:39:45
                                             3/5th my mistake. But your other 'facts' were incorrect. - DHighlander KC - 2/27 11:20:39
                                                  You made a completely inaccurate comment, and you are now - ummmm MU - 2/27 11:25:33
                                                       Obvious typo since the sentence right before identified the - DHighlander KC - 2/27 11:38:15
                                                            Just say: - ummmm MU - 2/27 11:52:54
                                             the 3/5 clause is so misinterpreted anyway. you realize it - blake1771 KC - 2/27 11:19:37
                                                  You should be directing these posts at DH. (nm) - ummmm MU - 2/27 11:25:49
                                                  Yes, it was a political compromise but one that actually - DHighlander KC - 2/27 11:24:36
                                                       these guys are "originalists" and imo, spend a lot of time - 90Tiger MU - 2/27 11:44:22
                                                            Constitutionally speaking, original intent is all that - ummmm MU - 2/27 11:56:55
                                                                 Exactly (nm) - pickle MU - 2/27 12:23:06
                    I wasn't talking about the Constitutional framework - ummmm MU - 2/27 09:46:31
                         So are food, shelter, clothing and employment. But states - DHighlander KC - 2/27 09:52:32
                              Under the framework of the Constitution, sure. (nm) - ummmm MU - 2/27 09:54:04




©2025 Fanboards L.L.C. — Our Privacy Policy   About Tigerboard