Welcome Guest

Some interesting history, and views, though

Posted on: December 2, 2016 at 07:14:28 CT
GA Tiger MU
Posts:
252561
Member For:
26.44 yrs
Level:
User
M.O.B. Votes:
0
the apparent fact he faces his responsibilities thru religious eyes bothers me. I do NOT want any religion combined with politics and policy. For that we may as well just elect muslims to office.

I did find this excerpt compelling however.

The Electoral College was corrupted from its original intent once states started dictating the votes of the Electors. The two biggest aggressors to the original system were from political parties and the switch to winner-take-all states. The rise of james-madisonpolitical parties, as George Washington prophetically predicted, has had a “baneful effect”[10] on our nation. They have all but ruined our Electoral College system. Originally Electors were free from political parties and their pledges. What mattered most was the character and qualifications of the candidate, not the viability of their path to victory (primaries) or the team that any candidate represented. The Electors were also free from these statewide popular vote contests that run all but two states today.[11] “When James Madison and Hamilton, two of the most important architects of the Electoral College, saw this strategy [statewide popular vote] being taken by some states, they protested strongly. Madison and Hamilton both made it clear this approach violated the spirit of the Constitution. Hamilton considered a pre-pledged elector to violate the spirit of Article II of the Constitution insofar as such electors could make no ‘analysis’ or ‘deliberate’ concerning the candidates. Madison agreed entirely, saying that when the Constitution was written, all of its authors assumed individual electors would be elected in their districts and it was inconceivable a ‘general ticket’ of electors dictated by a state would supplant the concept.
Report Message

Please explain why this message is being reported.

REPLY

Handle:
Password:
Subject:

MESSAGE THREAD

     If you had these misgivings about the process why would - DHighlander KC - 12/2 07:51:37
          He already resigned. It sounds like there is no mechanism - JeffB MU - 12/2 10:06:55
     Some interesting history, and views, though - GA Tiger MU - 12/2 07:14:28
          'the fact he faces his responsibilities thru religious eyes - JeffB MU - 12/2 10:54:07
          The EC was put in place because the founders did not - DHighlander KC - 12/2 07:55:24
               I agree that the EC would likely go away if enough electors - JeffB MU - 12/2 10:17:50
               I think a bigger issue, rarely discussed, is that of all - GA Tiger MU - 12/2 08:16:23
                    Why? Those out in the streets protesting Trump could have - DHighlander KC - 12/2 08:28:20
                         I'm thinking, as usual, long term. One of my few - GA Tiger MU - 12/2 08:37:20
                              But we do not vote long term. We vote for a person that - DHighlander KC - 12/2 09:56:59
          I agree that there would be significant unrest if Trump is - JeffB MU - 12/2 10:12:00




©2025 Fanboards L.L.C. — Our Privacy Policy   About Tigerboard