Welcome Guest

I wouldn't bet much money on that...............

Posted on: January 23, 2025 at 19:44:10 CT

Bulldog Bob Brown STL

Posts:

11117

Member For:

23.58 yrs

Level:

User

M.O.B. Votes:

they may affirm the birth right citizenship that exists today and put an end to this executive order, but something that hasn't been argued in 130+ years before the court will most likely get a day in court.

Remember, there are many, many folks who claim it is a "Living Constitution". This seems like one to test that theory.

Please explain why this message is being reported.

REPLY

MESSAGE THREAD

Federal judge denies Trump can amend the Constitution - SparkyStalcup MU - 1/23 16:02:08

why are you stupid? (nm) - pickle MU

- 1/23 19:14:58

Nothing gets by you(nm) - Panthera MU - 1/23 17:27:44

The whole purpose was to get it into courts, and then the - shorty MU

- 1/23 17:09:58

SCOTUS probably won't even grant certiorari on this, - SparkyStalcup MU - 1/23 18:49:42

I wouldn't bet much money on that............... - Bulldog Bob Brown STL - 1/23 19:44:10

^^^Yes^^^ what it was written for....The 1st and 2nd apply - tigertix MU - 1/23 17:32:36

another octogenarian in govt (nm) - SwampTiger MU - 1/23 17:03:32

Like the almost octagenarian that signed the EO? Nm - SparkyStalcup MU - 1/23 18:50:27

no, it's right there in your post (nm) - SwampTiger MU - 1/23 19:48:54

Yes, he's 83 and nowhere to go except on the bench like - tigertix MU - 1/23 17:38:19

RE: Yes, he's 83 and nowhere to go except on the bench like - SwampTiger MU - 1/23 17:52:12

did you know - 90Tiger STL - 1/23 16:57:43

"A judge is a perpetual law student who grades their own - Bulldog Bob Brown STL - 1/23 16:33:15

RE: Federal judge denies Trump can amend the Constitution - Outsider MU - 1/23 16:20:25

Trump is not amending the Constitution. Much like in Roe, - Spanky KU - 1/23 16:08:46

No. SCOTUS shouldnt hear this case, it's so bad. Of course, - SparkyStalcup MU - 1/23 18:54:23

this is correct. There are elements of Kim Ark that the - 90Tiger STL - 1/23 16:58:52

Even if they say the kid is a citizen. The parents are not(nm) - tman MU - 1/23 16:13:24

Where do people (millions) , like Vivek, who were born here - pinkman MU - 1/23 16:53:19

Vivek was born to legal residents and his mother - 90Tiger STL - 1/23 17:00:54

So basically, he wouldn't be a citizen under this EO sonce - SparkyStalcup MU - 1/23 18:56:56

Legal residence of parents could be a possible definition nm - pinkman MU - 1/23 17:08:21

Apparently it can be whatever you want, textualism be damned - SparkyStalcup MU - 1/23 18:58:28

if the EO were in affect when he was born, he wouldn't be - SwampTiger MU - 1/23 17:06:50

I know, his mom did become a citizen "shortly after" he was - 90Tiger STL - 1/23 18:03:10

Are you certain his parents were not citizens or - Spanky KU - 1/23 17:25:43

they weren't citizens, but not certain of visa/greencard - SwampTiger MU - 1/23 17:44:10

He was born to two Indian citizens in America - Columbian Gold MU - 1/23 17:03:34

RE: He was born to two Indian citizens in America - 90Tiger STL - 1/23 18:03:46

RE: Where do people (millions) , like Vivek, who were born here - Outsider MU - 1/23 16:59:57

That is not what the EO is about - Spanky KU - 1/23 16:26:02

Brilliant move by Trump to get the discussion started... - Logan STL - 1/23 16:07:12

Exactly - this is what he was looking to have done - 4TigersinMichigan MU - 1/23 16:29:33

Forcing it to SCOTUS is a very wise move - BigDave MU - 1/23 16:11:15