Welcome Guest

A question you may not have seen, pickle...

Posted on: November 27, 2023 at 20:41:35 CT

JeffB MU

Posts:

70262

Member For:

21.01 yrs

Level:

User

M.O.B. Votes:

Is punishing anyone (eg. a murderer or a rapist), by putting them in prison a moral way of dealing with that person and his/her crime?

Edited by JeffB at 20:42:18 on 11/27/23

Please explain why this message is being reported.

REPLY

MESSAGE THREAD

A question you may not have seen, pickle... - JeffB MU

- 11/27 20:41:35

that’s an odd question - pickle MU

- 11/27 21:50:30

Yes, this is a followup to the discussion that we had - JeffB MU

- 11/27 22:06:10

we didn’t have a discussion several years ago - pickle MU

- 11/27 22:11:05

How could one have a reasonable discussion if one party - JeffB MU

- 11/27 22:14:24

learn to pay attention, Jeff (nm) - pickle MU

- 11/27 22:16:20

Your dancing and dodging, indeed your cowardice & dishonesty - JeffB MU

- 11/27 22:23:29

Did you expect anything different ? - RHAYWORTH MU - 11/27 22:39:38

Open you mind and discuss. Worst case it gives you the - tman MU - 11/27 22:17:29

Typical. You don't discuss with anyone. You repost - tman MU - 11/27 22:13:11

i bet that's a new one, jeff - 90Tiger STL - 11/27 21:10:05

I'm a little perplexed as to why you so often feel the need - JeffB MU

- 11/27 21:57:34

defend pickle? I thought you were asking a question, not - 90Tiger STL - 11/28 05:58:47

I wasn't attacking pickle, but I was asking him a question. - JeffB MU

- 11/28 11:36:13

you’re a strange person, Jeff (nm) - pickle MU

- 11/28 12:53:47

always with the poor assumptions (nm) - pickle MU

- 11/27 22:03:29

You can fix that, by having a calm, rational, honest - JeffB MU

- 11/27 22:12:00

no, i can’t fix your perpetual victimhood - pickle MU

- 11/27 22:14:48

Irony. - JeffB MU

- 11/27 22:25:12

It would his first time ever. He can't even do it when he - tman MU - 11/27 22:14:30

So just answer. It isn't as if you qnd Pickle - tman MU - 11/27 21:15:22

There is no one, single answer. It's a broad, complex, - 90Tiger STL - 11/27 21:17:33

'You think putting people in jail for robbery creates - JeffB MU

- 11/27 22:10:22

I didn't mention "making them whole", Jeff. It's not - 90Tiger STL - 11/28 05:59:44

From my perspective, making crime victims whole is a key - JeffB MU

- 11/28 11:40:13

If a person pays the retribution - meatiger MU - 11/28 03:55:25

Some problems with your reply: - JeffB MU

- 11/28 12:19:15

sounds like an appeal to the majority - pickle MU

- 11/27 22:14:02

I was not basing my argument on an appeal to majority - JeffB MU

- 11/27 22:20:34

So why did you bring up - meatiger MU - 11/28 03:56:50

90Tiger brought up justice for victims of crime. What the - JeffB MU

- 11/28 11:43:01

because he’s dishonest - pickle MU

- 11/28 07:03:11

Your own dishonesty and hypocrisy, along with a complete - JeffB MU

- 11/28 11:45:34

don’t try to deflect, Jeff - pickle MU

- 11/28 12:48:37

Irony. YOU are the one trying to deflect, again, pickle. It - JeffB MU

- 11/29 17:21:07

Answer the question. You won't as usual. You deflect - tman MU - 11/27 21:20:09

I retract my request for an answer. it is complex, which - tman MU - 11/27 21:25:57

no, I provided material to answer, you're too lazy to - 90Tiger STL - 11/28 06:00:40

Well, both parties have to agree to an independent - Tigrrrr! MU

- 11/27 20:56:15

you don't know what the F you're talking about, so just - 90Tiger STL - 11/27 21:10:40

Neither does pickle(nm) - Tigrrrr! MU

- 11/27 23:28:55

90Tigeriny - JG MU

- 11/27 21:15:20

you're boring, JG, and uninteresting to me (nm) - 90Tiger STL - 11/27 21:17:51

I know - JG MU

- 11/27 21:20:36