Welcome Guest

Deflection and a bad one at that. The citizenship question

Posted on: July 10, 2019 at 13:21:01 CT

Floyd Turbo 99

Posts:

4859

Member For:

23.62 yrs

Level:

User

M.O.B. Votes:

Was used on 19 consecutive censuses.

Are those census results flawed and ultimately inaccurate due to that question?

Please explain why this message is being reported.

REPLY

MESSAGE THREAD

Hey democrats, do you want to know how many foreigners - hokie VT - 7/10 13:05:02

It’s no one’s business (nm) - pickle MU

- 7/10 15:26:58

Or how about asking them why they want a census of - Tigrrrr! MU

- 7/10 13:16:02

Public Safety. - raskolnikov MU - 7/10 13:33:33

It’s no one’s business - pickle MU

- 7/10 15:27:40

LMAO..... - Tigrrrr! MU

- 7/10 14:45:13

LOL, wow (nm) - MIZ45 MU - 7/10 14:03:05

Wouldn't that argument work for his too? (nm) - tcat KC - 7/10 13:40:24

Touche'. Great question. THEY NEED TO KNOW. Some - hokie VT - 7/10 13:24:29

So we can come get them, of course(nm) - Mormad MU - 7/10 13:17:28

Kick that football, Charlie Brown(nm) - Tigrrrr! MU

- 7/10 13:18:13

I'm just trying to figure out why you're worried about it - Mormad MU - 7/10 13:20:23

It's just funny the same folks who want to register every- - Tigrrrr! MU

- 7/10 13:23:44

I'm all for a Voter ID card - Mormad MU - 7/10 13:27:12

But that's racist. Black people always forget their wallets - hokie VT - 7/10 13:35:26

They have cell phones with data packages - Mormad MU - 7/10 13:37:21

Yup. Disparate impact is a manufactured problem that - hokie VT - 7/10 13:38:54

Need a count of people(nm) - raskolnikov MU - 7/10 13:13:06

Since the citizenship question was used 190 years - Floyd Turbo 99 - 7/10 13:16:23

Sad how craven the RIght is - raskolnikov MU - 7/10 13:18:54

What is your objection to knowing the citizenship of those - DoltfromSTL MU - 7/10 14:27:07

Deflection and a bad one at that. The citizenship question - Floyd Turbo 99 - 7/10 13:21:01

Times have changed dramatically - raskolnikov MU - 7/10 13:37:24

THAT hasn't changed. People have always - GA Tiger MU - 7/10 14:32:04

How would it be an undercount? Instead, we want an ACCURATE - DoltfromSTL MU - 7/10 14:30:29

Again with deflection, or is the question not answered - Floyd Turbo 99 - 7/10 13:53:07

illegal aliens are still illegal aliens - FootballRefugee MU

- 7/10 13:44:53

Either you knowingly lie here or you do not know what you - raskolnikov MU - 7/10 13:55:27

you're putting on an impressive display - FootballRefugee MU

- 7/10 14:29:10

It was "designed" over 200 years ago... - DoltfromSTL MU - 7/10 14:28:36

Raskolian "logic" says that if you don't want the socialists - hokie VT - 7/10 13:43:57

RE: Raskolian "logic" says that if you don't want the socialists - raskolnikov MU - 7/10 13:56:57

That was our discussion the other day with Rask - Mormad MU - 7/10 13:07:39

Exactly. So why do the socialists not want the question? nm - hokie VT - 7/10 13:11:23

I think the argument was because the source - Mormad MU - 7/10 13:14:42

You are one of the few left leaning posters capable or - hokie VT - 7/10 13:21:28

I lean left, but I try and start from a neutral position - Mormad MU - 7/10 13:25:30

That would mean that in idaho, one rep would have 10 sq mi - hokie VT - 7/10 13:29:36

Why? If you define the district in only a geographic way - Mormad MU - 7/10 13:32:39

You wouldn't have equal representation if one rep had a - hokie VT - 7/10 13:36:53

But his method in general would work. Once you knew the - DHighlander NWMSU - 7/10 14:45:41

Right, that's what it purports to do - Mormad MU - 7/10 13:38:43

If you think of it, that might cause folks to go to Montana - Mormad MU - 7/10 13:33:39