Welcome Guest

Probably more a case of Knizner being the heir to Yadi's

Posted on: December 5, 2018 at 16:25:24 CT

tigerdb MU

Posts:

58182

Member For:

24.35 yrs

Level:

User

M.O.B. Votes:

throne. But Kelly should still have significant value - even with his poor showing in the brief stint in SL. Weaver is definitely expendable - perhaps he does something in AZ, but he'd be the first of the young arms that I would want to part with.

Please explain why this message is being reported.

REPLY

MESSAGE THREAD

Derrick Goold says Cards are closing deal on Goldschmidt - KCT-BoneTiger MU

- 12/5 16:06:39

Now that is a great deal. Didn't give up much(nm) - Erwin Fletcher STL - 12/5 18:59:58

Ever drink Goldschlager? Had those flecks of gold in it. - HandBanana MU - 12/5 17:03:07

**** was huge back in the day... - Gyro MU - 12/5 17:07:03

Rumpleminz, Ice 101, I remember all those types of - HandBanana MU - 12/5 17:21:59

Could be a repeat of Heyward - I wonder what they are - alstl MU - 12/5 16:48:16

Wow - thats a steal - GoMizzouTigers MU - 12/5 16:25:12

Weaver and Carson are both major leaguers - Hoosier Daddy1 IU - 12/5 16:53:17

Weaver pitched in the major leagues. Poorly. Not one - TheWildcat STL - 12/5 16:25:38

Agreed, only opens up a spot in the rotation... - Gyro MU - 12/5 16:31:42

I really really really hope they can sign Goldschmidt and - TheWildcat STL - 12/5 16:33:17

I can pretty much guarantee they will let at least one walk - Hoosier Daddy1 IU - 12/5 16:54:37

Well the great thing about this deal... - Gyro MU - 12/5 16:34:51

Cards like to pocket a lot of that $$ they have plenty to - Hoosier Daddy1 IU - 12/5 16:55:17

No they won't but that's the thing... - Gyro MU - 12/5 17:06:22

Its not about the position, its about a generational - Hoosier Daddy1 IU - 12/5 17:13:09

The Cardinals don't need a draw... - Gyro MU - 12/5 19:11:45

I see O'Neill as more of an American League... - Gyro MU - 12/5 17:22:50

I agree he's an all or nothing guy and likely continues - Hoosier Daddy1 IU - 12/5 17:24:56

I'm honestly more interested... - Gyro MU - 12/5 19:06:28

Ozuna? I figured Goldschmidt at 3 and Ozuna at 4(nm) - TheWildcat STL - 12/5 16:37:09

I see him as more of a three... - Gyro MU - 12/5 17:04:51

Goldschmidt will hit 3rd (nm) - 90Tiger MU - 12/5 17:36:35

Weaver is a space cadet and Kelly hasn't shown he can hit - Macgrantt MU - 12/5 16:24:46

Great deal. Weaver and Kelly had questionable futures in STL - MidMoBaller4Life MU - 12/5 16:18:08

Awesome trade! - Uncle John MU

- 12/5 16:22:08

Weaver looks like a 4th or 5th in your rotation guy. I can't - TheWildcat STL - 12/5 16:24:35

I think that is Luke's ceiling as a starter and yeah, wow(nm) - MidMoBaller4Life MU - 12/5 16:26:50

He's capable of being really good - Mormad MU - 12/5 16:38:53

I've seen enough of him by now to know what I need to know - MidMoBaller4Life MU - 12/5 16:40:00

I'm not sad about losing him - Mormad MU - 12/5 16:47:57

Kelly isn't going to hit at the big league level. He looked - Floyd Turbo 99 - 12/5 16:20:43

Knizner is already better anyway(nm) - MidMoBaller4Life MU - 12/5 16:27:22

Yep, Kelly needed to be moved. (nm) - TheWildcat STL - 12/5 16:27:42

It benefits him and STL(nm) - MidMoBaller4Life MU - 12/5 16:28:20

Would this be considered "The Cardinal Way"? (nm) - kmawv8 MU - 12/5 16:13:23

Pretty sure he's white, yeah (nm) - Cosmo MU

- 12/5 16:15:15

Luke Weaver and Carson Kelly gone. Andrew Young too (nm) - KCT-BoneTiger MU

- 12/5 16:11:24

All that for one year with Goldschmidt? - kmawv8 MU - 12/5 16:16:35

Lol, - Uncle John MU

- 12/5 16:24:36

Lol, no. Cards got a steal (nm) - TheWildcat STL - 12/5 16:23:24

Dbacks were going to get nothing for him - kmawv8 MU - 12/5 16:24:44

I don't think they got a lot more than that just now. (nm) - TheWildcat STL - 12/5 16:25:09

Disagree, Cards didn't believe in Weaver and Kelly is gonna - tsutiger57 MU - 12/5 16:18:49

Probably more a case of Knizner being the heir to Yadi's - tigerdb MU - 12/5 16:25:24

Yep(nm) - MidMoBaller4Life MU - 12/5 16:28:00

Weaver is completely expendable. Agreed. (nm) - TheWildcat STL - 12/5 16:26:28

He's 25 and pitched in 30 games last year - kmawv8 MU - 12/5 16:21:28

Cards might have made the playoffs if they had sent someone - tigerdb MU - 12/5 16:31:42

I think Weaver profiles better as a reliever personally(nm) - MidMoBaller4Life MU - 12/5 16:35:31

If the Cards want him to stick around they will - Uncle John MU

- 12/5 16:26:15

Not if they extend him. This deal can't be judged - MU_gz MU

- 12/5 16:22:40

Done Deal. Bye Weaver (nm) - TheWildcat STL - 12/5 16:11:11

Thank God. (nm) - Uncle John MU

- 12/5 16:27:33

i think the deal is done. Hope it works out(nm) - Doc Stone MU

- 12/5 16:09:25

The pitchforks are really going to come out if they don't - TheWildcat STL - 12/5 16:08:18

Depends on how he plays. If he's good he won't get - Uncle John MU

- 12/5 16:23:59