Welcome Guest

2 things....

Posted on: March 5, 2018 at 16:24:09 CT
GapDaddy MU
Posts:
16515
Member For:
25.57 yrs
Level:
User
M.O.B. Votes:
0
1. that article states the NBA has decided against academies in the US.

2. Academies work elsewhere because there is a business market for players and academies can self-fund their talent identification and development.

This second point is very important: Academies like Real Madrid and Barcelona exist by identifying and developing talent and then selling that talent on an open market.

Young players sign with the academies that prove they can develop and sell players. Academies choose players whom they identify as having potential.

It's a true open market with teams in different leagues all over Europe buying and selling players.

That market doesn't exist in the US. There is only the NBA. The NBA currently has incentive to allow the college game to develop talent because the college game also provides marketing and branding for incoming talent -- fans of the college game at least follow some players into the NBA and the league, the shoe companies and the players benefits from that.

If you remove the marketing role that the college game currently provides, I'm not sure the shoe companies are even interested in young players anymore.
Report Message

Please explain why this message is being reported.

REPLY

Handle:
Password:
Subject:

MESSAGE THREAD

Euro soccer style academies the answer - wu-tangtiger MU - 3/5 13:54:04
     story says NBA has decided AGAINST academies in the US. - GapDaddy MU - 3/5 15:18:08
          both can happen - wu-tangtiger MU - 3/5 15:05:46
               2 things.... - GapDaddy MU - 3/5 16:24:09
     I think it comes down to how much TV presence the NBA - StaleyTiger MU - 3/5 14:16:22
          the talent, and the best competition is in college, now. - justwinbaby KC - 3/5 14:46:43
               The G League has better talent than college - wu-tangtiger MU - 3/5 14:49:14
          Some of the kids will forgo it if they can get paid - BOILERTIGER MU - 3/5 14:20:03
               This would be a terrible thing for these kids. (nm) - Uncle John MU - 3/5 14:32:52
     Won't that really hurt the NCAA's talent pool? - tgr MU - 3/5 14:10:02
          Probably would without changes on the NCAA's part. - zodiac6 JC - 3/5 14:11:50
               Yep, will be interesting to see how the schools adapt to - BOILERTIGER MU - 3/5 14:15:25
     Not buying it. Major issue is the number of kids who - jumbo73 MU - 3/5 13:59:35
          See below to make the point more specifically - jumbo73 MU - 3/5 14:11:35
          I like the academy idea for high school age - wu-tangtiger MU - 3/5 14:06:20
               how can Baseball have such an elaborate farm system, - justwinbaby KC - 3/5 14:38:30
               The first step IMO is ending the amateurism charade. - zodiac6 JC - 3/5 14:09:38
                    It would have to be limited in such a way that schools like - myself MU - 3/5 14:22:44
                         The richest schools already get the best players - zodiac6 JC - 3/5 14:30:48
                              Poor argument. "It's already an unlevel playing field so who - myself MU - 3/5 14:38:24
                                   The poor argument is that OSU and Texas will buy up - zodiac6 JC - 3/5 14:40:17
                                        The top 25 richest schools (including fans and boosters) - myself MU - 3/5 14:44:55
                                             Jerry Jones would have a minor league team in Fayetteville - hogfan14 ARK - 3/5 19:02:54
                                             I think you're vastly overestimating how much those schools - zodiac6 JC - 3/5 14:51:39
                                                  It would become a bidding war for each player. (nm) - myself MU - 3/5 14:51:59
                                                       I'm fine with that. - zodiac6 JC - 3/5 15:03:11
                                                            Most AD's are already in the "red", they can't afford to - myself MU - 3/5 15:06:48
                                                                 The bulk of the money wouldn't come from the schools. - zodiac6 JC - 3/5 15:16:30
                                                                      The money would come from many sources, especially - myself MU - 3/5 15:22:27
                         Schools wouldn’t really have to pay the athletes - wu-tangtiger MU - 3/5 14:25:22
                              As I said, that would ruin college sports. Schools with the - myself MU - 3/5 14:30:13
                                   Compare OSU and Purdue recruiting now. - zodiac6 JC - 3/5 14:36:36
                                        It would get even worse. Schools like Missouri, Illinois,... - myself MU - 3/5 14:39:35
                                             How much do you think Texas would spend on a guy - zodiac6 JC - 3/5 14:40:43
                                                  Texas A&M just gave a $75 million contract to Jimbo Fisher, - myself MU - 3/5 14:47:23
                                                       And Alabama already gets the best players. - zodiac6 JC - 3/5 14:52:15
                                                            Off the top of my head, James Foster had an offer from - myself MU - 3/5 14:59:00
                                                                 And he ended up at A&M. - zodiac6 JC - 3/5 15:09:47
                                                                      He decommitted after we went 1-5, which was understandable.. - myself MU - 3/5 15:20:01
                                                                           Lots of low/mid-level schools would still be able to recruit - zodiac6 JC - 3/5 15:25:18
                                                                                We'll have to agree to disagree on this. (nm) - myself MU - 3/5 15:34:43
                                   My proposal - BOILERTIGER MU - 3/5 14:35:25
                                        the attraction college has over minor leagues, - justwinbaby KC - 3/5 14:42:02
                                        That’s what the G League is for - wu-tangtiger MU - 3/5 14:40:08
                                        Major pass on that for me. - zodiac6 JC - 3/5 14:38:57
                                   Colleges could restrict that to a degree - wu-tangtiger MU - 3/5 14:33:08
                              Kinda what I was thinking - BOILERTIGER MU - 3/5 14:27:31
                    Yea there’s definitely a way to allow college - wu-tangtiger MU - 3/5 14:11:28
                         Those two things are mutually exclusive. - zodiac6 JC - 3/5 14:12:20




©2024 Fanboards L.L.C. — Our Privacy Policy   About Tigerboard