Welcome Guest
Sign In | Register

Did you make a fact-jump there? I don't know

Posted on: March 4, 2020 at 17:01:06 CT
Mormad MU
Posts:
54895
Member For:
18.07 yrs
Level:
User
M.O.B. Votes:
0
not a student of Rothbard's ideas, but my question is this:

Is the 2nd paragraph true, or is it what you believe his ideas to be? I don't know that he believes that others can't intervene and rescue the child. If the parents then prevented assistance from coming, wouldn't they be infringing on the child's right to life?

So, while the parents don't have the obligation to do anything, it would be an affirmative act if they prevented others from doing so. Does that make sense?
Report Message

Please explain why this message is being reported.

REPLY

Handle:
Password:
Subject:

MESSAGE THREAD

Unanswered questions - MrBlueSky MU - 3/4 14:00:24
     Where? And will you answer my question - pickle MU - 3/4 14:02:27
          Rothbard routinely leaves out that word: - JeffB MU - 3/4 14:40:41
               no - ashtray UF - 3/4 14:41:59
                    I don't think he is - Mormad MU - 3/4 14:47:48
                         regardless, he’s very confused (nm) - pickle MU - 3/4 14:51:17
                              Your obligation here is to detail where what I have said - JeffB MU - 3/4 14:54:39
                                   I have no such obligation - pickle MU - 3/4 14:56:05
                                        and neither you nor Rothbard nor Ashtray nor anyone else - JeffB MU - 3/4 14:58:44
                                             you are very, very confused, Jeff - pickle MU - 3/4 14:59:41
                                                  I want to read while you explain this one(nm) - Mormad MU - 3/4 15:00:49
                                                       explain what? (nm) - pickle MU - 3/4 15:11:42
                                                            Why you think he is confused - Mormad MU - 3/4 15:12:36
                                                                 RE: Why you think he is confused - pickle MU - 3/4 15:18:17
                                                                      Ahh, the typical smokescreen of insults pickle relies upon - JeffB MU - 3/4 15:36:28
                                                                           not even going to look at that vomit (nm) - pickle MU - 3/4 15:43:24
                                                                                I'm not surprised. Cowards always run when exposed. (nm) - JeffB MU - 3/4 15:49:33
                                                       He won't. This is the part of his dialogue where he throws - JeffB MU - 3/4 15:02:15
                                                            Lol, You nailed that perfectly. - RHAYWORTH MU - 3/4 15:06:39
                                                                 The result may be immoral to most of us, or utterly stupid - Mormad MU - 3/4 15:09:55
                                                                      Where was I confused? I know full well that he agrees with - JeffB MU - 3/4 15:17:08
                                                                           Ok, here's where I found it confusing on your part - Mormad MU - 3/4 15:23:19
                                                                                OK, I think I see where the confusion lies. I assume that - JeffB MU - 3/4 16:07:54
                                                                                     Which is why Ashtray said you were correct - Mormad MU - 3/4 16:16:49
                                                                                          What about a case where a mother tweets that she has not - JeffB MU - 3/4 16:30:28
                                                                                               Did you make a fact-jump there? I don't know - Mormad MU - 3/4 17:01:06
                                                                                                    it’s a “fact” jump - pickle MU - 3/4 19:05:37
                                                                                                    it's a fact jump (nm) - 90Tiger STL - 3/4 17:35:20
                                                                           you still get it wrong - pickle MU - 3/4 15:19:03
                                                                                More dishonest dissembling from you. You always have to - JeffB MU - 3/4 15:21:11
                                                                                     there’s no dishonesty here, Jeff - pickle MU - 3/4 15:26:50
                                                                                          Of course there is pickle. You are dishonest in the extreme(nm) - JeffB MU - 3/4 16:46:53
                                             correct! - ashtray UF - 3/4 14:59:20
                         And since they have no "legal" obligation - MrBlueSky MU - 3/4 14:49:56
                         because most folks don't understand rights - ashtray UF - 3/4 14:48:46
                              True, different issues - Mormad MU - 3/4 14:51:10
                                   morality is different person to person, though. (nm) - MrBlueSky MU - 3/4 14:51:53
                                        It is, and it's different with the same person - Mormad MU - 3/4 14:55:05
                                        but in reality, society has moral norms - ashtray UF - 3/4 14:54:34
                                             But so what, at least in an anarchistic society. If society - JeffB MU - 3/4 15:19:06
                                                  "society" doesn't "say" anything, Jeff (nm) - 90Tiger STL - 3/4 17:36:21
                                                  society doesn’t think or act - pickle MU - 3/4 15:37:27
                    You must mean Rothbard doesn't understand what you - JeffB MU - 3/4 14:44:57
                         One this is clear Jeff: YOU have no right to determine if - glue MU - 3/4 14:51:49
                              Do you think mothers have a right to decide whether their - JeffB MU - 3/4 15:10:03
                                   What's important is that neither you nor I have - glue MU - 3/4 15:44:56
                                   do you believe you have the right to force anyone - ashtray UF - 3/4 15:16:10
                         where does he use the word obligation in that copy/paste? (nm) - ashtray UF - 3/4 14:46:52




©2024 Fanboards L.L.C. — Our Privacy Policy   About Tigerboard