 |
|
You end by asking a separate question, imo. The founding of
Posted on: December 16, 2019 at 11:25:51 CT
hokie VT
Posts:
68148
Member For:
9.66 yrs
Level:
User
M.O.B. Votes:
0
pakistan and the founding of israel have some similarities. I am no historian but will stipulate that prager's assertions are correct.
The problem with his logic i think is that he makes assertions about the thinking and the heart of the people who question israel's right to exist. Anyone who disagrees he says is an anti semite.
That in my opinion is preposterous.
If, and i am not necessarily agreeing here, but IF the founding of pakistan and israel are the same and only israel's legitimacy is questioned, that does not in my opinion say that everyone who questions israel's right to exist is an antisemite.
There may be other factors at play. I will not assign a motive to someone else's beliefs. I don't know and i will not pretend to know the heart and the mind of people i have never met who hold an opinion with which i disagree.
The problem with his logic i think is that he makes assertions about the thinking and the heart of the people who question israel's right to exist. Anyone who disagrees he says is an anti semite.
That in my opinion is preposterous.
If, and i am not necessarily agreeing here, but IF the founding of pakistan and israel are the same and only israel's legitimacy is questioned, that does not in my opinion say that everyone who questions israel's right to exist is an antisemite.
There may be other factors at play. I will not assign a motive to someone else's beliefs. I don't know and i will not pretend to know the heart and the mind of people i have never met who hold an opinion with which i disagree.
Please explain why this message is being reported.
MESSAGE THREAD
- 
You end by asking a separate question, imo. The founding of - hokie VT - 12/16 11:25:51