Welcome Guest

RE: Prager argues that being anti-Israel = anti-Jew...

Posted on: December 16, 2019 at 11:24:28 CT

raskolnikov MU

Posts:

188057

Member For:

24.78 yrs

Level:

User

M.O.B. Votes:

I have a ginormous affection for the Jews. I think they do and outta have a state. The Canaanites should have one too, though and ZIONIST Strains inside the Israeli State are a terrible influence on achieving peace.

Please explain why this message is being reported.

REPLY

MESSAGE THREAD

Prager argues that being anti-Israel = anti-Jew... - JeffB MU

- 12/16 10:55:45

RE: Prager argues that being anti-Israel = anti-Jew... - raskolnikov MU - 12/16 11:24:28

Zionism is the advocacy of the state of Israel, per - JeffB MU

- 12/16 11:59:37

I like prager and i like the yids, but i disagree with him - hokie VT - 12/16 11:09:05

We agree here, at least in part. Weird(nm) - raskolnikov MU - 12/16 11:26:07

My opinion has been that the way Israel was (re) established - JeffB MU

- 12/16 11:14:57

You end by asking a separate question, imo. The founding of - hokie VT - 12/16 11:25:51

Prager & Wikipedia assert that Zionism is the advocacy of - JeffB MU

- 12/16 12:04:04

Sorry to cop out, but i don't know enough (or frankly - hokie VT - 12/16 12:16:49

But you’ll blindly support giving them foreign aid - pickle MU

- 12/16 13:32:45

He is specifically addressing just the issue of anti-Zionism - JeffB MU

- 12/16 12:21:37

This may or may not answer your question. At this point, - hokie VT - 12/16 12:30:51

Do you think the founding of Israel and the way land - pickle MU

- 12/16 13:34:13

anti-Semite ≠ anti-Zionist, however. You mostly argued - JeffB MU

- 12/16 13:23:30

wow - ashtray UF - 12/16 12:33:37

lol no - pickle MU

- 12/16 12:10:00

So you are anti-Zionist? Israel does not have a right to - JeffB MU

- 12/16 12:20:00

Jews are individual people. Israel is a government. - TigerMatt STL - 12/16 11:02:15

I agree, but he wasn't making the case that we have to like - JeffB MU

- 12/16 11:16:01

That still has nothing to do with Jews as a people. It is - TigerMatt STL - 12/16 11:32:27

I think there are a few different issues in play here. - JeffB MU

- 12/16 12:14:15

Except, Jewish history for two millenia, from the - GA Tiger MU - 12/16 11:06:58

that’s one reason why he’s an idiot - pickle MU

- 12/16 10:59:12

Logical discussion is not your strong suit, as you demonstra - JeffB MU

- 12/16 11:17:10