Welcome Guest

Best baseball player - you would argue endlessly

Posted on: May 30, 2018 at 21:57:11 CT

alstl MU

Posts:

29832

Member For:

24.54 yrs

Level:

User

M.O.B. Votes:

over the term athlete. I'd argue one of the world level wrestlers would probably be a better athlete. Maybe J'Den Cox or Ben Askren who has prospered in MMA.

Please explain why this message is being reported.

REPLY

MESSAGE THREAD

By the time his career is over, is Scherzer the greatest - tigerNkc MU

- 5/30 20:18:10

Best baseball player - you would argue endlessly - alstl MU - 5/30 21:57:11

i think he was referring - meatiger MU - 5/30 22:25:59

Multiple MMA fighters have been the champion - alstl MU - 5/31 07:48:59

Winslow is in the Hall of fame (nm) - Uncle John MU

- 5/30 21:44:23

so will Scherzer and will have greater accomplishments (nm) - tigerNkc MU

- 5/30 21:53:33

He does not even have 150 wins - meatiger MU - 5/30 22:24:51

if he wins the Cy Young again (4th and 3rd straight) he's in - tigerNkc MU

- 5/31 00:29:46

I don't doubt that (nm) - Uncle John MU

- 5/30 22:01:30

No consideration for Phil Bradley?(nm) - STL1DFW STL - 5/30 21:23:39

Corky! How's it going - Carlos Rossi KC - 5/30 21:56:54

State Douche Bag of Missouri ruins another thread.. - STL1DFW STL - 5/30 22:49:53

The Offical State Douche Bag of Missouri shows - STL1DFW STL - 5/30 22:07:30

No - not everyone...in fact you are the only one known as - Carlos Rossi KC - 5/30 22:18:23

RE: No - not everyone...in fact you are the only one known as - STL1DFW STL - 5/30 23:13:39

Oh & nobody hardly ever responds to any - STL1DFW STL - 5/30 22:53:04

You are the only one calling anyone that & consumed with - STL1DFW STL - 5/30 22:45:56

In summation, there is only one reason you would have to - STL1DFW STL - 5/30 23:02:06

maybe I should have said the most accomplished(nm) - tigerNkc MU

- 5/30 21:12:34

As rephrased, looks like a good call (nm) - MUTGR MU - 5/30 22:26:08

I'd say yes to most accomplished nm - mizzoumurfkc MU

- 5/30 21:25:19

here's a list most won't agree with - Macgrantt MU - 5/30 21:02:24

Greatest athlete or most successful athlete? There’s a - playhard NWMSU - 5/30 20:41:16

Haley - colonel angus beef KC - 5/30 21:51:56

J Maclin, A Smith, A Peeler, I Kinzler are all better - playhard NWMSU - 5/30 20:43:25

I don't think anyone would suggest Scherzer is more athletic - zodiac6 JC - 5/30 20:46:15

His question said greatest athlete, that’s why I asked - playhard NWMSU - 5/30 20:53:17

I haven't seen Maclin pitch - FootballRefugee MU

- 5/30 20:50:15

I'd bet Scherzer has an edge in arm and hitting - zodiac6 JC - 5/30 20:57:18

you're being narrow here - FootballRefugee MU

- 5/30 21:14:31

no (nm) - Hickeytime MU

- 5/30 20:22:16

Who then? Going for his 4th Cy Young. Can’t beat that(nm) - tigerNkc MU

- 5/30 20:23:48

Winslow - zodiac6 JC - 5/30 20:44:46

Gets my vote. (nm) - Hickeytime MU

- 5/30 20:58:48

Is Winslow really GOAT for his position? - Grasslands MU - 5/30 20:55:57

Impossible to say - zodiac6 JC - 5/30 21:10:10

Probably Gonzalez and Sharpe - Grasslands MU - 5/30 21:34:29

He may be already. - alwaysright MU - 5/30 20:19:43