Welcome Guest

So, hypothetically, if Trump calls up the Nat'l Guard to

Posted on: April 4, 2018 at 15:31:47 CT

TigerJackSwartz MU

Posts:

64229

Member For:

17.43 yrs

Level:

User

M.O.B. Votes:

guard the border, and certain states refuse the call, what would happen?

Please explain why this message is being reported.

REPLY

MESSAGE THREAD

So, hypothetically, if Trump calls up the Nat'l Guard to - TigerJackSwartz MU

- 4/4 15:31:47

Should carpet bomb all criminals trying to enter illegally - Fourth and Long MU - 4/4 16:23:40

So level the cities clustered around each of the 48 - catbirdseat MU

- 4/4 16:26:27

The Guard is a component of the Army - tigerfans3 MU - 4/4 16:04:27

The U.S. Mexican Border is 4 states - catbirdseat MU

- 4/4 15:36:46

Should be regular army and marines units - Spanky KU - 4/4 15:54:39

What regs allow army/navy to enforce domestic laws?(nm) - Mo Texan MU - 4/4 15:59:39

Protecting our national security is not enforcing domestic - Spanky KU - 4/4 16:13:33

It's called the Insurrection Act and none, I repeat none - Mo Texan MU - 4/4 16:21:24

He has quite a bit more latitude as C-in-C than you give - Spanky KU - 4/4 18:22:35

This isn't a debate. There is an actual law on the books - catbirdseat MU

- 4/4 16:16:13

Congress may not limit the President's power to defend the - Spanky KU - 4/4 16:23:11

What instance are you talking about?(nm) - Mo Texan MU - 4/4 16:24:29

This instance - Spanky KU - 4/4 17:05:59

Cite the lay that says the military can't stop invaders - tigerfans3 MU - 4/4 16:20:34

What foreign force is heading our way?(nm) - Mo Texan MU - 4/4 16:23:14

The caravan in this case - tigerfans3 MU - 4/4 16:26:15

Really, the caravan of Honduran children-SMH(nm) - Mo Texan MU - 4/4 16:29:34

One duty of the military is to repel boarders - tigerfans3 MU - 4/4 16:07:39

The military is not authorized to enforce domestic law - Mo Texan MU - 4/4 16:17:09

The courts might settle the argument later but homeland - tigerfans3 MU - 4/4 16:24:52

1st, there is no riot now taking place on the border, 2nd - Mo Texan MU - 4/4 16:36:19

There won't be a riot if the military holds their ground - tigerfans3 MU - 4/4 16:39:17

State(nm) - Mo Texan MU - 4/4 16:41:50

google.. - tigerfans3 MU - 4/4 17:12:25

Yea, that Canadian border is pretty big. - catbirdseat MU

- 4/4 16:10:04

You can't read? People are coming to cross into America - tigerfans3 MU - 4/4 16:15:35

We are not being invaded on our Northern border - Spanky KU - 4/4 16:14:22

Invaded?????????/ - Mo Texan MU - 4/4 16:38:12

Yes.. invaded. - Spanky KU - 4/4 18:33:42

I strongly disagree with this categorization. (nm) - DC Jayhawk KU - 4/4 21:06:23

That is sad - Spanky KU - 4/4 21:24:44

Deploying federal troops on U.S. soil as a permanent - catbirdseat MU

- 4/4 15:57:20

Why would he call up the NG? - Spanky KU - 4/4 15:34:22

Because Obama & Bush called in the NG! - tigerdb MU - 4/4 15:44:30

you do a lot of assuming and projecting (nm) - 90Tiger MU - 4/4 15:50:02

called it...and there's little teetee with her nonresponsive - tigerdb MU - 4/4 17:12:51

He already has Spanks!! - Silas MU - 4/4 15:39:54

Stupid move... He should send Regular Army units to do that - Spanky KU - 4/4 15:46:24

Posse Comitatus Act. - catbirdseat MU

- 4/4 15:39:05

You should learn what the PCA actually says - Spanky KU - 4/4 15:47:08

Deals with the Army and Navy enforcing DOMESTIC policies. - jonesin - 4/4 15:44:33

Only deals with Army and Air Force - Spanky KU - 4/4 16:15:19

Thats Right ! Marines can do whatever they want - Uncle Fester USMC - 4/4 16:20:00

Does not restrict the Navy at all. - TGR84 MU - 4/4 15:52:35