Welcome Guest

No more so than Trebia, Trasimene, and Cannae

Posted on: January 5, 2018 at 19:29:23 CT
Gallowglass USMC
Posts:
38460
Member For:
26.45 yrs
Level:
Moderator
M.O.B. Votes:
0
helped Carthage avoid Zama.

The North could have lost more than one Gettysburg and still handily won the war. To think otherwise is either ignorance of Southern romanticism of the War.

The South needed a much larger population to field enough troops to compete with the North. The South needed an economy based on actual industry that produced more than what slavery could produce. The South lacked the rail and port infrastructure to move troops and resources and trade with foreign powers.

https://www.shmoop.com/civil-war/economy.html


Edited by Gallowglass at 19:36:12 on 01/05/18
Report Message

Please explain why this message is being reported.

REPLY

Handle:
Password:
Subject:

MESSAGE THREAD

It seems some of you need a lesson... - TennesseeWaltz1 UT - 1/5 10:08:01
     Here's a lesson I'm sure you don't know - StlOx MU - 1/5 16:29:00
          Joe Shelby. One of the greatest cavalry men in the war - Nohawks MU - 1/5 17:39:24
     Stupid but humorous. nm - Die-Hard MU - 1/5 14:29:42
     LOL thanks, that describes 90% of Missourians....nm - tigertix MU - 1/5 13:50:31
     RE: It seems some of you need a lesson... - sarasotatiger MU - 1/5 13:33:22
     Good stuff. Thanks for sharing.(nm) - McKinneyTiger MU - 1/5 12:23:18
     Oh, for the love of God.(nm) - MOOZOO MU - 1/5 11:58:32
     a little history lesson about Missouri - nippermo MU - 1/5 11:45:00
          Some good posts in this thread. Could of really used some - BigTime SEMO - 1/5 17:50:53
          Missouri did not vote to secede and your history is wrong - KC rules MU - 1/5 17:07:46
               It sounds like you are wrong on secession. - BigTime SEMO - 1/5 17:43:39
                    RE: It sounds like you are wrong on secession. - KC rules MU - 1/5 19:22:19
                         Huh? Are you really going with that the elected governement - BigTime SEMO - 1/5 21:21:17
          Forgot to mention we also had slaves, but maybe thats a - GA Tiger MU - 1/5 14:05:10
          RE: a little history lesson about Missouri - sarasotatiger MU - 1/5 13:57:58
          RE: I feel the same way about Indiana... - TennesseeWaltz1 UT - 1/5 12:47:42
               "sympathizing state"??? You dumb **** - hoosierdaddy MU - 1/5 13:49:15
     FYI... - turnersmotiger MU - 1/5 11:14:46
     As someone who has - Nohawks MU - 1/5 10:23:41
          ^^^AWESOME!(nm) - coachHiggzy MU - 1/5 11:46:54
          From 1840 to 1860 - Tptiger MU - 1/5 11:41:53
               Understood and agreed with - Nohawks MU - 1/5 11:50:37
                    Jackson County was pro-union - StlOx MU - 1/5 15:59:56
     The South was doomed when Jackson died at Chancellorsville - MU-TULSA MU - 1/5 10:13:51
          Doomed by poor leadership from the start - StlOx MU - 1/5 16:14:03
               RE: My great great grandfather never owned a slave... - TennesseeWaltz1 UT - 1/5 20:05:41
          The South was doomed when it seceded - Gallowglass USMC - 1/5 12:20:34
               RE: The South was doomed when it seceded - TennesseeWaltz1 UT - 1/5 12:49:14
                    No more so than Trebia, Trasimene, and Cannae - Gallowglass USMC - 1/5 19:29:23
                    RE: The South was doomed when it seceded - sarasotatiger MU - 1/5 13:26:32
                         RE: Lost slavery? - TennesseeWaltz1 UT - 1/5 13:37:54
                              RE: Lost slavery? - sarasotatiger MU - 1/5 13:56:11
                                   Those farmers - StlOx MU - 1/5 16:05:48
          RE: The South was doomed... - TennesseeWaltz1 UT - 1/5 10:16:30
               RE: The South was doomed... - sarasotatiger MU - 1/5 13:38:16




©2025 Fanboards L.L.C. — Our Privacy Policy   About Tigerboard