Welcome Guest

It had to have been "settled" in a lower court. The

Posted on: April 17, 2017 at 16:11:54 CT

hokie VT

Posts:

68169

Member For:

9.66 yrs

Level:

User

M.O.B. Votes:

supremes essentially agreed with the lower court. And didn't want to waste time proving that the moon was in fact NOT made of cream cheese.

Next case.

Please explain why this message is being reported.

REPLY

MESSAGE THREAD

The Gorsuch confirmation already paying dividends? - Spanky KU - 4/17 15:20:24

What was the vote split? - JG MU

- 4/17 17:20:12

I can't imagine any of the Democrat appointed justices - Spanky KU - 4/17 19:00:12

It's too bad that the court has to weigh in on the obvious - Tigerfish MU - 4/17 15:42:09

Excellent. We have a constitution for the united states, - hokie VT - 4/17 15:34:22

Good lord, you're ignorant - pickle MU

- 4/17 17:52:15

You might want to read the 14th Amendment - Mo Texan MU - 4/17 15:37:34

Which has nothing to do with BEING ABLE TO LIVE HERE - GA Tiger MU - 4/17 15:50:56

It was written for people. - DC Jayhawk KU - 4/17 16:10:11

Yell more little guy - Mo Texan MU - 4/17 15:52:34

thats cool you find other men cute(nm) - MizSecZou MU - 4/17 16:47:18

And ?(nm) - Mo Texan MU - 4/17 17:41:44

you like... - MizSecZou MU - 4/17 20:10:09

You might want to read the ruling - Spanky KU - 4/17 15:41:22

My post is in reference to his remark that the US - Mo Texan MU - 4/17 15:47:21

Fair enough.... it is a very valid point. - Spanky KU - 4/17 15:55:17

No bad, enjoy the conversation and pushing hokie a little - Mo Texan MU - 4/17 16:04:21

So you think that anyone who sneaks across the border is - hokie VT - 4/17 15:54:28

Not at all, but once in our jurisdiction and controlled by - Mo Texan MU - 4/17 15:58:37

It was argued. It lost. Next case. nm - hokie VT - 4/17 16:02:24

That point was not argued as far as I can tell - Mo Texan MU - 4/17 16:06:52

It had to have been "settled" in a lower court. The - hokie VT - 4/17 16:11:54

Continue to ignore the point which has nothing to do with - Mo Texan MU - 4/17 17:40:21

Thanx Ho. They were not denied protection, they were - hokie VT - 4/17 15:41:22

See above for merit clarification - Mo Texan MU - 4/17 15:50:36

Wouldn't you prefer - meatiger MU - 4/17 15:36:54

Seems to me the case was essentially dismissed for being - hokie VT - 4/17 15:39:30

because it sets precedent and a stake in the ground - meatiger MU - 4/17 15:45:12

SCOTUS did not grant certiorari. Nm - SparkyStalcup MU - 4/17 15:42:26

Right. The court decided that "...the case did not present - hokie VT - 4/17 15:46:59

you are correct - FootballRefugee MU

- 4/17 16:06:29

His appointment has no effect on that as only 4 Justices - Mo Texan MU - 4/17 15:31:44

I'll pray for the women and children. - Toger STL - 4/17 15:24:50

Why does your conscience need clearing? - Spanky KU - 4/17 15:28:24

But since Mexico gives them nothing on which to live, - GA Tiger MU - 4/17 15:44:13

Even worse.. Mexico will put them in prison if they - Spanky KU - 4/17 15:56:14

yes, but you won't pay for them either. - RHAYWORTH MU - 4/17 15:28:17

how is that paying dividends - meatiger MU - 4/17 15:24:02

It lets a sane decision by a lower court stand - Spanky KU - 4/17 15:29:11

Maybe like most issues - meatiger MU - 4/17 15:31:28

Doubtful... - Spanky KU - 4/17 15:40:35