Welcome Guest
Sign In | Register

I am not sure it's disagreeable. Rogers was faster

Posted on: February 10, 2025 at 15:59:58 CT
TheWildcat MU
Posts:
164464
Member For:
17.34 yrs
Level:
User
M.O.B. Votes:
0
at his peak than Mahomes ever was and he had better running stats.

Rogers peaked as a complete package at probably 33-35ish.
Report Message

Please explain why this message is being reported.

REPLY

Handle:
Password:
Subject:

MESSAGE THREAD

An honest but unpopular opinion: Mahomes is near the end of - zounami MU - 2/10 15:23:15
     They've tried to turn him into a 3-yard-out passer - Tptiger MU - 2/11 12:53:09
     RE: An honest but unpopular opinion: Mahomes is near the end of - JangoFett MU - 2/10 19:20:33
     You're clueless about the NFL as you are college - Diamond Dave MU - 2/10 17:17:17
     Attention whore here, nothing more. (nm) - JayRoy KC - 2/10 16:52:47
          a maladjusted person seeking fulfillment in an odd way (nm) - hou4mu MU - 2/10 17:20:05
               I knew the opinion, though true, would be unpopular here (nm) - zounami MU - 2/10 17:28:17
                    Whoosh. That’s the point flying over your head - hou4mu MU - 2/10 17:40:34
                         no, the point is that you're lashing out with an ad hominem - zounami MU - 2/10 18:08:30
                    He can be effective for 12+ more years. And your - Diamond Dave MU - 2/10 17:33:23
     Only in STL KC hating fans' wet dreams - Beakerbasher KC - 2/10 16:46:31
          RE: You underestimate the hate around the country..... - Stlmetz ARMY - 2/11 07:09:27
     Youd do realize that Brady wsa 9-8 in the 8 postseasons - tigerNkc KC - 2/10 16:41:16
          like I said, he had a much longer shelf life due to being a - zounami MU - 2/10 16:42:42
     give me the list of QBs that peaked at 29 - Joeboo MU - 2/10 15:49:24
          sue isn't serious, he thinks he drives TB click numbers - Macgrantt MU - 2/10 16:20:49
               sue isn't serious, he thinks he drives TB click numbers - Macgrantt MU - 2/10 16:41:45
               you've got it all figured out, Macgrantt... - zounami MU - 2/10 16:38:21
                    Sure do have you calca/zounami et al figured out - Macgrantt MU - 2/10 16:47:24
                         oh how I dream of becoming a moderator like you briefly were - zounami MU - 2/10 17:02:40
                              what's your view on why you're mobbed off most days - Macgrantt MU - 2/10 17:08:11
                                   double handles of a few disgruntled users (nm) - zounami MU - 2/10 17:19:11
                                        so as I expected, you think you're a victim, blameless - Macgrantt MU - 2/10 17:22:36
          for the record - Joeboo MU - 2/10 15:55:05
               none of them relied on their mobility/athleticism like PM * - zounami MU - 2/10 15:55:31
                    try again - Joeboo MU - 2/10 15:57:37
                         Rogers is the greatest running white QB by a wide margin.. - TheWildcat MU - 2/10 15:58:25
                              That's bullshlt. Steve is by far #1 in that category - alwaysright MU - 2/10 18:10:44
                              Tarkenton was before both of those guys(nm) - Diamond Dave MU - 2/10 16:34:28
                                   And not as good as either (nm) - TheWildcat MU - 2/10 16:43:29
                                        All 3 are HOF'ers. That's pretty damn good company for - Diamond Dave MU - 2/10 17:19:24
                              SY was a better runner than Rogers - Joeboo MU - 2/10 16:07:52
                                   Yea, I guess that may be true. I remember an aging Steve - TheWildcat MU - 2/10 16:13:00
                                        His run against the Vikings in 88 is prolly the greatest QB - alwaysright MU - 2/10 18:13:39
                    ... Peyton Manning was slower than molasses, a typical - zounami MU - 2/10 15:56:48
                    Aaron Rogers was a lot more mobile than PH is. (nm) - TheWildcat MU - 2/10 15:56:39
                         yep - Joeboo MU - 2/10 16:00:25
                              And though he doesn't have the SB wins, I still say - TheWildcat MU - 2/10 16:01:43
                                   Rogers age 37 season in 2020 is bonkers - Joeboo MU - 2/10 16:03:08
                         I strongly disagree with that, but for the sake of argument - zounami MU - 2/10 15:58:18
                              Rogers peaked from age 28-38 - Joeboo MU - 2/10 16:02:02
                              I am not sure it's disagreeable. Rogers was faster - TheWildcat MU - 2/10 15:59:58
                                   He didn't depend on it. He was a better passer than PM... - zounami MU - 2/10 16:02:32
                                        Who is PH? (nm) - Lt. J. Dangle MU - 2/10 16:06:38
                                             Pearl Harbor man, c'mon... - zounami MU - 2/10 16:14:31
                                                  I assumed it was a typo until I saw it done 3 different - Lt. J. Dangle MU - 2/11 09:06:24
                                        I am not arguing that Mahomes has more talent than Rogers - TheWildcat MU - 2/10 16:03:17
     Brady’s last superbowl win was against Atlanta - El-ahrairah BAMA - 2/10 15:31:14
          So those don't count?(nm) - Erwin Fletcher STL - 2/11 08:05:41
     Jesus Christ you are really dumb... - Carlos Rossi KC - 2/10 15:28:57
          don't shoot the messenger (nm) - zounami MU - 2/10 15:32:20
               So you are Jonesin... - Carlos Rossi KC - 2/10 15:36:22
                    jonesin for what? (nm) - zounami MU - 2/10 15:37:54
                         RE: jonesin for what? (nm) - Breadtruck MU - 2/10 17:29:42
     kind of a dumb take, man (nm) - Seagull MU - 2/10 15:27:39
          which part do you disagree with and why? (nm) - zounami MU - 2/10 15:35:54
               the entire premise is dumb (nm) - Seagull MU - 2/10 15:36:22
                    how so? (nm) - zounami MU - 2/10 15:38:05
                         watch the Patriots/Giants SB again - Seagull MU - 2/10 15:40:16
                              that's a non-sequitur (nm) - zounami MU - 2/10 15:40:52
                                   no, it's what you're basing your premise on - Seagull MU - 2/10 15:42:28
                                        you don't think Mahomes has been trending downward over - zounami MU - 2/10 15:45:15
                                             not at all - Seagull MU - 2/10 15:54:39
                                                  fair enough... we can agree to disagree (nm) - zounami MU - 2/10 15:55:10
                                                       He is mentally better. Mahomes used to try to play hero ball - TheWildcat MU - 2/10 15:57:48
                                                            You're engaging with a troll about a topic he - kmawv8 MU - 2/10 15:59:39
                                                                 no, he was discussing something you didn't want - 90Tiger STL - 2/10 16:37:18
                                                                      No. - kmawv8 MU - 2/10 20:51:18
                                                                      you mean people who pretend they don't follow the nfl - phrejd KC - 2/10 16:38:13
                                                                           another disgruntled KC fan who can't handle the truth (nm) - zounami MU - 2/10 16:40:04
                                                                 no, he's engaging in civil discourse unlike you (nm) - zounami MU - 2/10 16:05:58
     Even Brady - meatiger MU - 2/10 15:26:58
     RE: An honest but unpopular opinion: Mahomes' is near the end of - AWOLTiger KC - 2/10 15:26:19
          but in the past, Mahomes could have scrambled and eluded - zounami MU - 2/10 15:31:42
               You don't follow the NFL (nm) - kmawv8 MU - 2/10 15:32:14
                    I don't have to follow it closely to draw such an - zounami MU - 2/10 15:32:42
                         "Closely" was never in your quote. - kmawv8 MU - 2/10 15:33:45
                              don't be so pedantic (nm) - zounami MU - 2/10 15:35:10
                                   your use of pedantic here is.....pedantic - Macgrantt MU - 2/10 16:16:58
     OK Jonesin(nm) - tman MU - 2/10 15:25:58
     "I don't follow the NFL" -zounami (nm) - kmawv8 MU - 2/10 15:25:52
          that doesn't stop him from being an expert on the NFL (nm) - Seagull MU - 2/10 15:28:14
               He doesn't play chess either, but it doesn't stop him from - Lt. J. Dangle MU - 2/10 16:11:59
               In case anyone thinks I'm making up a quote - kmawv8 MU - 2/10 15:29:34




©2025 Fanboards L.L.C. — Our Privacy Policy   About Tigerboard