Welcome Guest

Electoral College reforms ...

Posted on: August 2, 2024 at 10:18:11 CT
Fourth and Long MU
Posts:
14724
Member For:
12.62 yrs
Level:
User
M.O.B. Votes:
0
Under our current electoral college rural communities are disenfranchised. Look at a county by county results map from previous election cycles and you can see that the major population centers (big cities) still control their respective states electoral votes.

Geographically even California and New York have more conservative counties than liberal, yet they don't collectively have the population to overcome the big cities/counties. This defeats the original purpose as to why our forefathers created the electoral college in the first place and what has led to our ever widening political divide.

Proposed remedies:

A. One electoral vote per county, nationwide. This would solve current geographic in balances. And restore the original intent of our forefathers.

B. Keep the current system in place but require all states to implement, county by county voting with one vote per county to determine the state's overall electoral vote. This also provides a voice for smaller rural areas within each state.

A quick look at our geographic voting history, shows geographically that the country is nearly 90% conservative, yet by population it's appropriately 50/50. As someone in the rural Midwest, I don't feel that we get a fair shake and that our country is controlled large population centers, primarily on the coasts.

Illinois is a local example of this disparity. Cook County (Metro-Chicago) controls the
entire state despite not being politically aligned with 90% of state's counties.

Regardless if my premise is right or wrong, it's hard to argue that it's not one of the reasons for our current ideologically divisions.
Report Message

Please explain why this message is being reported.

REPLY

Handle:
Password:
Subject:

MESSAGE THREAD

Electoral College reforms ... - Fourth and Long MU - 8/2 10:18:11
     RE: Electoral College reforms ... - patriot MU - 8/2 11:45:10
     So vote by land mass - meatiger MU - 8/2 10:44:28
          I agree, it's stupid.(nm) - CulturedDan KC - 8/2 10:45:47
               On top of that - meatiger MU - 8/2 10:48:15
                    One day’s travel on horseback. (nm) - haeffb MU - 8/2 10:49:31
                         Certainly not every state - meatiger MU - 8/2 10:50:06
                              Or a retarded horse(nm) - CulturedDan KC - 8/2 10:53:01
     Good thing local elections have a lot more impact - Eggs MU - 8/2 10:36:23
     Better idea. Let land vote. - haeffb MU - 8/2 10:29:13
          How bout you gotta spin a globe and find your state on - cybertyger MU - 8/2 12:27:08
          There’s an idea(nm) - redngray MU - 8/2 11:02:42
          I don't think it does. - CulturedDan KC - 8/2 10:30:27
     Eliminate - raskolnikov MU - 8/2 10:27:46
          also the most wildly successful in the history of Earth (nm) - 90Tiger STL - 8/2 12:02:28
          Why does Rask hate the USA? - kp83 MU - 8/2 11:48:07
          Pure democracy is stupid. Don't be stupid(nm) - AWOLTiger KC - 8/2 11:18:10
          So LA and New York can decide every election. - Tigrrrr! MU - 8/2 10:50:07
          There are other First past the post countries and some do - CulturedDan KC - 8/2 10:38:47
               I think rank voting could be interesting - meatiger MU - 8/2 10:49:31
                    I might vote if that was the case. - CulturedDan KC - 8/2 10:54:16
                         I also understand 75% of the population wouldn't - CulturedDan KC - 8/2 10:54:53
                              So dumb people get frustrated and don’t vote. - haeffb MU - 8/2 11:01:23
                                   nah, they'll have operators at their door ensuring they - 90Tiger STL - 8/2 12:04:00
                                   Hopefully(nm) - CulturedDan KC - 8/2 11:05:38
                              Not sure exactly how it would work - meatiger MU - 8/2 11:00:51
          That was done on purpose to prevent a dictatorship - mizzouSECedes STL - 8/2 10:38:45
               RE: That was done on purpose to prevent a dictatorship - KC rules MU - 8/2 10:55:42
          Yeah, the Founding Fathers and Constitution were Stupid - kp83 MU - 8/2 10:35:53
          That would be the clearest path to succession - Th8tnTiger MU - 8/2 10:34:04
          Except maybe Venezuela - mu7176grad MU - 8/2 10:33:11
               That's a really good point - mizzouSECedes STL - 8/2 10:39:59
     Modify it slightly - CulturedDan KC - 8/2 10:21:48
          I think this is generally the best - meatiger MU - 8/2 10:45:24
               Unfortunately, yes(nm) - CulturedDan KC - 8/2 10:46:02
          The left would never win another election, so won't happen - ZouMiz STL - 8/2 10:25:42
               Not sure about that- they win majority in congress and the - CulturedDan KC - 8/2 10:30:01




©2025 Fanboards L.L.C. — Our Privacy Policy   About Tigerboard