Welcome Guest
Sign In | Register

Even if one agrees with the 1898 decision, there are only 2

Posted on: July 25, 2024 at 17:27:58 CT
Spanky KU
Posts:
141323
Member For:
20.24 yrs
Level:
User
M.O.B. Votes:
0
avenues for that decision to be overturned or cemented:

1) A new law is passed that contradicts v Wong Kim Ark and the court has a "do-over" and either affirms or rejects the 1898 decision (as happened in Dobbs)

or

2) A clearly written Constitutional Amendment is written that affirms or abolishes birthright citizenship and ratified (and removes SCOTUS from the equation)

Edited by Spanky at 17:28:11 on 07/25/24
Report Message

Please explain why this message is being reported.

REPLY

Handle:
Password:
Subject:

MESSAGE THREAD

Ending Birthright Citizenship - haeffb MU - 7/25 15:59:56
     A SCOTUS ruling established birthright citizenship - Spanky KU - 7/25 16:31:49
     "Subject to the jurisdiction thereof" is the part - Columbian Gold MU - 7/25 16:09:19
          how can the child of 2 persons literally not under the - 90Tiger STL - 7/25 16:40:30
     It would only take a proper interpretation of the - ummmm MU - 7/25 16:06:24
          Thanks, SCOTUS needs to overturn this and thus ending the - tigertix MU - 7/25 16:53:36
          Proper interpretation by whom? - haeffb MU - 7/25 16:23:32
               by anyone serious about the topic and not politically - 90Tiger STL - 7/25 16:38:07
                    Well, you and I can’t end it. - haeffb MU - 7/25 16:47:16
               A case would need to come before the court from someone - Spanky KU - 7/25 16:33:21
               By anyone trying to understand what the intent of - ummmm MU - 7/25 16:30:36
                    As I said... a case would need to come before the court to - Spanky KU - 7/25 17:20:58
                    Interesting discussion. My thanks to you and Spanky. - haeffb MU - 7/25 16:38:41
                         ...because of (in their view) an improper prior interpretati - 90Tiger STL - 7/25 16:39:35
                              Even if one agrees with the 1898 decision, there are only 2 - Spanky KU - 7/25 17:27:58
          that's a good post (nm) - Sal CMSU - 7/25 16:08:34




©2024 Fanboards L.L.C. — Our Privacy Policy   About Tigerboard