Welcome Guest

Sign In | Register

Proper interpretation by whom?

Posted on: July 25, 2024 at 16:23:32 CT

haeffb MU

Posts:

12043

Member For:

25.70 yrs

Level:

Moderator

M.O.B. Votes:

0

Can Congress write a law to clarify what the Framers of the 14th intended ? Or would SCOTUS have to first rule that the 1898 case (I confess I haven’t yet looked it up) was inappropriately decided?

Further - asylum seekers have entered the country legally. They are at least seeking to be “subject to the jurisdiction thereof.”

Are their children born in the US citizens?

Please explain why this message is being reported.

REPLY

MESSAGE THREAD

Ending Birthright Citizenship - haeffb MU - 7/25 15:59:56

A SCOTUS ruling established birthright citizenship - Spanky KU - 7/25 16:31:49

"Subject to the jurisdiction thereof" is the part - Columbian Gold MU - 7/25 16:09:19

how can the child of 2 persons literally not under the - 90Tiger STL - 7/25 16:40:30

It would only take a proper interpretation of the - ummmm MU - 7/25 16:06:24

Thanks, SCOTUS needs to overturn this and thus ending the - tigertix MU - 7/25 16:53:36

Proper interpretation by whom? - haeffb MU - 7/25 16:23:32

by anyone serious about the topic and not politically - 90Tiger STL - 7/25 16:38:07

Well, you and I can’t end it. - haeffb MU - 7/25 16:47:16

A case would need to come before the court from someone - Spanky KU - 7/25 16:33:21

By anyone trying to understand what the intent of - ummmm MU - 7/25 16:30:36

As I said... a case would need to come before the court to - Spanky KU - 7/25 17:20:58

Interesting discussion. My thanks to you and Spanky. - haeffb MU - 7/25 16:38:41

...because of (in their view) an improper prior interpretati - 90Tiger STL - 7/25 16:39:35

Even if one agrees with the 1898 decision, there are only 2 - Spanky KU - 7/25 17:27:58

that's a good post (nm) - Sal CMSU - 7/25 16:08:34

©2024 Fanboards L.L.C. — Our Privacy Policy About Tigerboard