Welcome Guest

You didn't read it. Or you would know I stated

Posted on: November 20, 2023 at 21:19:02 CT

tman MU

Posts:

36270

Member For:

21.73 yrs

Level:

User

M.O.B. Votes:

That there ism only one version. Then spelled it out, and explained why NAP does not apply to third parties getting involved in incidents they are not otherwise involved in

Edited by tman at 21:19:34 on 11/20/23

Please explain why this message is being reported.

REPLY

MESSAGE THREAD

Flow chart - pickle MU

- 11/20 20:56:58

so if society does something offensive or harmful - JG A - 11/21 01:35:39

lol, good grief (nm) - MIZ45 MU - 11/21 09:57:12

try again (nm) - pickle MU

- 11/21 07:51:02

you got the someones mixed up (nm) - SwampTiger MU - 11/21 07:34:23

You three probably do - JG A - 11/21 12:05:07

who defines offensive?(nm) - tigerinhogtown STL - 11/20 22:42:11

the individual (nm) - pickle MU

- 11/20 22:52:25

sounds pretty subjective to me and unenforceable(nm) - tigerinhogtown STL - 11/21 10:56:24

So if 15 upstanding black utes find someone offended them - Tigrrrr! MU

- 11/21 08:08:42

And if he is wrong? Or others then join?(nm) - tman MU - 11/20 22:59:57

you aren’t paying attention - pickle MU

- 11/20 23:26:50

I am and that is why your postion is a problem - tman MU - 11/20 23:35:27

There is no problem except with your inability to follow - TigerMatt STL - 11/21 01:09:43

Pickle and meat(nm) - tman MU - 11/20 22:47:42

THE GRAND CUCUMBER HAS SPOKEN!!!!!! - Tigrrrr! MU

- 11/20 21:58:32

I thought you were against helping others - meatiger MU - 11/20 21:22:58

You are allowed as third party to use force against another - tman MU - 11/20 21:26:18

Big problem with that is who is perceiving harm. pickle - JeffB MU

- 11/20 22:25:27

His position also assumes that the third party - tman MU - 11/20 22:36:01

no (nm) - pickle MU

- 11/20 22:38:58

Yes. Otherwise third party is now an aggressor himself - tman MU - 11/20 22:41:39

no and no - pickle MU

- 11/20 22:53:03

So third party can be wrong without repercusion? - tman MU - 11/20 23:01:38

you will always be ignorant of rights - pickle MU

- 11/20 22:30:36

yet when people see that - meatiger MU - 11/20 21:33:54

No it isn't. All that does is escalate the situation. - tman MU - 11/20 21:38:35

Now heading to straw mans I see - meatiger MU - 11/20 21:40:14

Nope. under NAP you don't have any right to get involved - tman MU - 11/20 21:41:38

Not the NAP I know old man(nm) - tman MU - 11/20 21:03:10

you don’t understand the NAP - pickle MU

- 11/20 21:08:24

Actually I did. Look the original post up - tman MU - 11/20 21:12:25

i read it when you replied to Swamp - pickle MU

- 11/20 21:16:16

Let's discuss pickle. I will start - tman MU - 11/20 21:23:54

You didn't read it. Or you would know I stated - tman MU - 11/20 21:19:02

the NAP certainly applies to 3rd parties(nm) - meatiger MU - 11/20 21:35:08

No it doesn't. First no one has the right to initiate force - tman MU - 11/20 21:36:33

not true - meatiger MU - 11/20 21:37:15

Not under NAP. Under human decency yes(nm) - tman MU - 11/20 21:40:40

he’s not smart (nm) - pickle MU

- 11/20 21:37:55

Link you NAP policy that states third parties - tman MU - 11/20 21:42:54

So you think if a 19 year old is mugging grandma - meatiger MU - 11/20 21:46:13

Straw man, but NAP says it is not anyone else's business - tman MU - 11/20 21:48:29

that’s not a straw man (nm) - pickle MU

- 11/20 21:59:39

Yes it is. Take your loss(nm) - tman MU - 11/20 22:04:45

it isn’t. it’s literally your argument applied - pickle MU

- 11/20 22:11:34

You are a troll, an absolutes, and incapable - tman MU - 11/20 22:13:18

So by that - meatiger MU - 11/20 21:49:14

Are either you or pickle going to link a NAP - tman MU - 11/20 21:54:39

The NAP allows for force to be used against force - meatiger MU - 11/20 21:56:31

It clearly does. I did not add it. Link yours(nm) - tman MU - 11/20 22:05:40

Yes, unless they are directly recipient of force against - tman MU - 11/20 21:50:56

Can you link a version of NAP - meatiger MU - 11/20 21:55:09

Here - tman MU - 11/20 22:03:45

neither of those state the NAP - pickle MU

- 11/20 22:13:24

Why don't you state it(nm) - tman MU - 11/20 22:15:00

use the search feature - pickle MU

- 11/20 22:22:07

Why dint you just restate it. Surely you have it saved - tman MU - 11/20 22:33:51

Under support - meatiger MU - 11/20 22:09:49

So you have pointed out that others feel differently - tman MU - 11/20 22:32:37

Why don't you link it?(nm) - tman MU - 11/20 22:12:05

It was in a link you provided(nm) - meatiger MU - 11/20 22:12:30

Ok. I will look at the footnote, as I said i would do if - tman MU - 11/20 22:14:31

I simply copied something that you posted - meatiger MU - 11/20 22:16:57

Which say some people disagree with the NAP I posted - tman MU - 11/20 22:37:21

it explained the NAP - meatiger MU - 11/20 22:38:22

Post your NAP. Surely it isn't simply that some people - tman MU - 11/20 22:43:11

you did for me - meatiger MU - 11/20 22:44:30

No. But surely you have your NAP starting with it applies - tman MU - 11/20 22:45:42

i have never posted "my NAP" - meatiger MU - 11/20 23:03:38

So you have no NAP that you believe in. You just - tman MU - 11/20 23:10:50

I do not need a written NAP - meatiger MU - 11/20 23:14:55

So you demand mine and have none of your own - tman MU - 11/20 23:24:08

ok(nm) - meatiger MU - 11/20 23:44:04

You can counter(nm) - tman MU - 11/21 01:06:16

he has yet to even post it - pickle MU

- 11/20 22:39:59

I mean in what he posted - meatiger MU - 11/20 22:41:31

It said some people disagree and apply it to third - tman MU - 11/20 22:44:49

Yes, some people disagree on various parts of everything(nm) - meatiger MU - 11/20 23:04:08

So post yours and I will read why your source - tman MU - 11/20 23:12:07

Now link yours(nm) - tman MU - 11/20 22:04:19

Smarter than you.(nm) - tman MU - 11/20 21:39:43

you didn’t state the NAP - pickle MU

- 11/20 21:24:18

Are you going to engage as I most certainly stated - tman MU - 11/20 21:27:34

When you admit you are wrong here let's talk NAP(nm) - tman MU - 11/20 21:14:01