Welcome Guest
Sign In | Register

the stupid and uninformed flows so effortlessly with you

Posted on: November 10, 2020 at 10:25:17 CT
Ace AU
Posts:
28230
Member For:
5.27 yrs
Level:
User
M.O.B. Votes:
0
Big comment from Kavanaugh just now: "I tend to agree with you" that the case is "very straightforward" under our severability precedents. Those precedents (including an opinion authored by Kavanaugh last term) say there is usually a strong presumption in favor of severability.

Kavanaugh could vote to declare the individual mandate unconstitutional (his questions so far suggest he thinks it it) but also vote to sever the mandate and leave the rest of the law in place. He hinted at such an approach last term.
Report Message

Please explain why this message is being reported.

REPLY

Handle:
Password:
Subject:

MESSAGE THREAD

Ouch - Ace AU - 11/10 10:16:36
     if it or part of it is unconstitutional then it is SC job - fatrat MU - 11/10 10:33:25
          Notice The Idiot disagrees with you. That is of course - hokie VT - 11/10 10:39:45
               read the Constitution - pickle MU - 11/10 10:41:50
                    I am somewhat in agreement - Iam4Mizzou MU - 11/10 11:06:05
     "Congress wouldn't abolish this Unconstitutional law, so why - zounami MU - 11/10 10:26:00
          You poor thing...somebody won't - mizzoumurfkc KC - 11/10 10:33:50
          because that is not SCOTUS’ role - pickle MU - 11/10 10:31:20
               it literally says that's the role(nm) - Iam4Mizzou MU - 11/10 10:37:05
                    M v M disagrees (nm) - pickle MU - 11/10 10:40:49
                         it's weird how you can take a simple concept - Iam4Mizzou MU - 11/10 10:41:51
                              read the plain text. it’s right there - pickle MU - 11/10 10:44:09
                                   just so I understand, your issue is that - Iam4Mizzou MU - 11/10 11:03:02
                                        yes, the issue is that the Constitution is a dead document - pickle MU - 11/10 11:08:49
                                   You are correct on this one. That hurt to type(nm) - tman MU - 11/10 10:45:28
                                        Wrong. If a partisan Congress passes an Unconstitutional - zounami MU - 11/10 10:58:13
                                             that is 100% incorrect - pickle MU - 11/10 11:00:03
     It's their job to strike down laws that are unconstitutional - zounami MU - 11/10 10:23:37
          no it isn’t (nm) - pickle MU - 11/10 10:30:26
               um, yes it is(nm) - Iam4Mizzou MU - 11/10 10:33:40
                    um, no it isn’t (nm) - pickle MU - 11/10 10:41:09
                    not when it goes against aspects of laws which are - Ace AU - 11/10 10:36:23
     That's pretty rich coming from Roberts - Sal MU - 11/10 10:23:06
          I'd be very cirucmspect of any information or quote posted - hokie VT - 11/10 10:28:56
     His job is to rule on Constitutionality, last I checked(nm) - Spanky KU - 11/10 10:21:18
          Exactly. How did this clown get nominated and confirmed?... - zounami MU - 11/10 10:24:59
     Even with lib Roberts on your side still 5-4. ACA is gone(nm) - TigerMatt STL - 11/10 10:19:38
          Don't be so sure. - DC Jayhawk KU - 11/10 10:33:51
          the stupid and uninformed flows so effortlessly with you - Ace AU - 11/10 10:25:17
               In the case of severability, the Obama care act - tman MU - 11/10 10:47:55
               “Obviously it was justified under the taxing clause, but now - Spanky KU - 11/10 10:32:02
               “Why couldn’t we believe when Congress zeroed out the tax - Spanky KU - 11/10 10:31:13
                    that is still a tax, Spanky. - Ace AU - 11/10 10:37:26
                         No.. a zero rate is not a tax(nm) - Spanky KU - 11/10 11:11:18
                              nope - Ace AU - 11/10 11:36:18
                                   Wrong.... a zero tax rate is not the same as taxes being - Spanky KU - 11/10 12:07:14
               Obamacare collapses without the mandate. (nm) - zounami MU - 11/10 10:26:52




©2024 Fanboards L.L.C. — Our Privacy Policy   About Tigerboard