Welcome Guest
Sign In | Register

"Minarchists and libertarians"?? minarchists are libertarian

Posted on: May 23, 2017 at 10:02:25 CT
lqf2b8 MU
Posts:
74274
Member For:
15.59 yrs
Level:
User
M.O.B. Votes:
0
so there is no need to be redundant. How you can say that their is not an inconsistency between "governments should exist" and an anarchists take on libertarianism is not reconcilable logically.



Minarchism is not nor could it ever be a waypoint to anarchism when the basis of minarchism is that a government is necessary to ensure the NAP is not violated while the anarchist take is that a government is intrinsically a violation of it.


It would take a dramatic paradigm shift for a minarhist to become an anarchist not a gradual progression via a waypoint.
Report Message

Please explain why this message is being reported.

REPLY

Handle:
Password:
Subject:

MESSAGE THREAD

Libertarianism - pickle MU - 5/23 08:44:59
     has there ever been a successful society driven by - Fire Marshall Bill MU - 5/23 09:06:11
          which societies in all of history (and current) would you - 90Tiger MU - 5/23 09:25:31
               yeah, that's a little gray - Fire Marshall Bill MU - 5/23 09:27:48
                    no, you should ask first "what societies are / were successf - 90Tiger MU - 5/23 09:31:42
                         I'm not dismissing anything - Fire Marshall Bill MU - 5/23 09:45:50
                              You are entirely dismissive - pickle MU - 5/23 10:01:02
                         before that ask "what is a successful society" (nm) - MizzouAstro MU - 5/23 09:33:18
                              the only successful society that I am aware of is an - lqf2b8 MU - 5/23 09:35:28
     seems like a minarchist's take on libertarianism not an - lqf2b8 MU - 5/23 09:02:36
          minarchism and anarchism are points on the spectrum - pickle MU - 5/23 09:08:40
               I know the difference but like I said, the Boaz quote you - lqf2b8 MU - 5/23 09:11:57
                    It's not a minarchist or anarchist take - pickle MU - 5/23 09:18:34
                         correct me if I am wrong but you have stated very often - lqf2b8 MU - 5/23 09:24:35
                              Correct, the State solely exists by force - pickle MU - 5/23 09:53:26
                                   "Minarchists and libertarians"?? minarchists are libertarian - lqf2b8 MU - 5/23 10:02:25
                                        All minarchists are libertarians - pickle MU - 5/23 10:42:47
                              You are focusing on the 2nd paragraph not the - TigerMatt STL - 5/23 09:44:40
                                   even the highlighted text advocates laws to be put in place - lqf2b8 MU - 5/23 09:50:20
                                        Well, yeah...laws can exist without gvmt - pickle MU - 5/23 09:55:08
                                             why are we discussing whether or not the passage you - lqf2b8 MU - 5/23 10:11:39
                                                  I haven't cherry picked anything - pickle MU - 5/23 10:43:58
                         RE: It's not a minarchist or anarchist take - Fire Marshall Bill MU - 5/23 09:20:05




©2025 Fanboards L.L.C. — Our Privacy Policy   About Tigerboard