Welcome Guest
Sign In | Register

Is it an act of war? Sure. Is it initiation or resp./defense

Posted on: April 14, 2017 at 09:00:53 CT
pickle MU
Posts:
265867
Member For:
25.80 yrs
Level:
User
M.O.B. Votes:
4
Are these bases within the United States?

Edited by pickle at 09:01:23 on 04/14/17
Report Message

Please explain why this message is being reported.

REPLY

Handle:
Password:
Subject:

MESSAGE THREAD

Question for libs and pickle. If NKorea attacks Japan or - hefeweizen MU - 4/14 08:13:44
     RE: Question for libs and pickle. If NKorea attacks Japan or - sarasotatiger MU - 4/14 09:42:55
     If pickle really believes that the world's people should - tigerNkc KC - 4/14 08:48:51
          I don't know how I can make my positions any clearer for you - pickle MU - 4/14 08:57:43
               If US bases are attacked by NKorea, is that an act of war?(nm) - hefeweizen MU - 4/14 08:58:34
                    Is it an act of war? Sure. Is it initiation or resp./defense - pickle MU - 4/14 09:00:53
                         No, they are clearly NOT in the US but they are US property - hefeweizen MU - 4/14 09:03:31
                              How could I know they are clearly not in the US - pickle MU - 4/14 09:04:58
                                   lol, goddam. Why do you do this? It was a very - hefeweizen MU - 4/14 09:07:00
                                        Yes, it was a straightforward question - pickle MU - 4/14 09:10:20
                                             goddam man, this is why nobody takes you seriously. The - hefeweizen MU - 4/14 09:12:38
                                                  I'm sorry you're struggling to express yourself - pickle MU - 4/14 09:22:50
                                                       what an a**hole you are when faced with a quandary(nm) - hefeweizen MU - 4/14 09:28:18
                                                            You mess with the pickle.... you get the🦄 - Emoji Man MSU - 4/14 09:56:37
                                                            What quandary??? (nm) - pickle MU - 4/14 09:40:18
                                                                 self defense, property rights, natural rights etc etc. (nm) - hefeweizen MU - 4/14 09:42:09
                                                                      There's no quandary here, Reino. - pickle MU - 4/14 09:49:49
                                                       ðŸ¦„ WELCOME TO PICKLETOPIA 🦄 - Emoji Man MSU - 4/14 09:24:22
     Why do you think the US would be targeted? - Silas MU - 4/14 08:32:38
          That's not an answer to my question(nm) - hefeweizen MU - 4/14 08:37:47
               It is the basis to your question. I am questioning the false - Silas MU - 4/14 08:39:56
                    No, that is a pussy, cop out answer. Of course it is a - hefeweizen MU - 4/14 08:41:36
                         Why not provide a well thought out, reasoned approach to the - Silas MU - 4/14 08:43:26
                              dont respond if you are too ****ing stupid to answer(nm) - MizSecZou MU - 4/14 08:46:59
                              this is so dumb. It is a hypothetical question that doesnt - hefeweizen MU - 4/14 08:44:50
                                   Ask a relevant question. - Silas MU - 4/14 08:46:07
                                        goddam, lol(nm) - hefeweizen MU - 4/14 08:46:34
                                        Create a new handle... - MizSecZou MU - 4/14 08:46:31
     Troops immediately leave the area and come back to the USA. - Evenflow MU - 4/14 08:30:19
          So if attacked there, no response?(nm) - hefeweizen MU - 4/14 08:38:16
               Love the NEOCON hat you're wearing this morning.(nm) - Evenflow MU - 4/14 08:42:27
                    huh? I simply asked a question. I haven"t given my opinion - hefeweizen MU - 4/14 08:42:56
                         If attacked (or certainly before) I would close the bases - Evenflow MU - 4/14 08:45:45
                              fair enough. That's an an answer(nm) - hefeweizen MU - 4/14 08:46:22
                                   It's the same answer he gave before (nm) - pickle MU - 4/14 08:48:17
                                        I just wanted clarification. Why are you being obtuse?(nm) - hefeweizen MU - 4/14 08:49:52
                                             No one in this thread but you is being obtuse (nm) - pickle MU - 4/14 08:58:08
                                                  I asked a simple question, part of which you chose to ignore - hefeweizen MU - 4/14 08:59:31
                                                       No one has ignored any part of your question - pickle MU - 4/14 09:02:19
                                                            you did below. Totally ignored part of my question. Why - hefeweizen MU - 4/14 09:04:14
                                                                 No I didn't (nm) - pickle MU - 4/14 09:07:07
                                                                      Why are you being dishonest? - hefeweizen MU - 4/14 09:08:45
                                                                           I'm not. (nm) - pickle MU - 4/14 09:10:42
                                                                                yes you are. Why? I have no idea. I suspect it is because - hefeweizen MU - 4/14 09:14:16
                                                                                     Not at all. - pickle MU - 4/14 09:24:30
                                                                                          Sure I do and the reason why you are being a ***** is - hefeweizen MU - 4/14 09:30:02
                                                                                               No, you don't. And how am I being an a**hole? - pickle MU - 4/14 09:41:36
                                                                                                    you are being an a**hole by purposely ignoring the - hefeweizen MU - 4/14 09:44:21
                                                                                                         I haven't ignored your question - pickle MU - 4/14 09:50:36
               He just gave you the response (nm) - pickle MU - 4/14 08:38:39
          A brain washed battle for the centuries (nm) - ummmm MU - 4/14 08:31:57
     Pickle--assume fetal poisiton and apologize - mu7176grad MU - 4/14 08:28:54
          Don't be stupid (nm) - pickle MU - 4/14 08:31:37
               You dominate the stupid category - mu7176grad MU - 4/14 08:45:02
                    Iran - pickle MU - 4/14 08:47:41
     We should draw some redlines, make some speeches, go to - hokie VT - 4/14 08:27:01
     Remove all US troops and craft and close all US bases (nm) - pickle MU - 4/14 08:24:13
          Your world view is so comically stupid I'm having a hard - Emoji Man MSU - 4/14 08:43:53
               You don't know anything about my world view - pickle MU - 4/14 08:49:45
                    As you near 170k posts I think everyone has a pretty good - Emoji Man MSU - 4/14 08:59:14
                    a border-less world. We should help those less fortunate in - tigerNkc KC - 4/14 08:52:50
                         Wrong - pickle MU - 4/14 09:03:44
          That's not an answer to my question(nm) - hefeweizen MU - 4/14 08:36:43
               It is. Q: what should the US do if... - pickle MU - 4/14 08:38:02
                    Just so I get this right, the US bases are attacked and your - hefeweizen MU - 4/14 08:40:34
                         Do I need to draw you a picture? - pickle MU - 4/14 08:45:35
                         Your original question does not make that specification, but - ummmm MU - 4/14 08:42:58
                              yes it does, learn to read(nm) - hefeweizen MU - 4/14 08:49:28
                                   No, it doesn't (nm) - ummmm MU - 4/14 08:51:59
                                        learn to read - hefeweizen MU - 4/14 08:53:10
                                             I read that part. It does not say that US bases are - ummmm MU - 4/14 08:55:40
                                                  what? lol. It cannot be any clearer. It says most likely - hefeweizen MU - 4/14 09:01:19
                                                       Is an attack on a US base an attack on Japan? (nm) - ummmm MU - 4/14 09:03:18
                                                            The probably consider it to be. Would you consider it an - hefeweizen MU - 4/14 09:08:06
                                                                 If the attack is on the US base, I would consider it - ummmm MU - 4/14 09:08:45
                                                                      ok, and your response would be what?(nm) - hefeweizen MU - 4/14 09:09:37
                                                                           LMFAO. Goddamn, Reino (nm) - pickle MU - 4/14 09:12:17
                                                                           Remove the troops, close the base, bring the people and - ummmm MU - 4/14 09:11:41
                                                                                ok, fair enough. Do you think that response would encourage - hefeweizen MU - 4/14 09:15:51
                                                                                     Discourage. The whole military would be here waiting. - ummmm MU - 4/14 09:17:05
                                                                                          So, you would leave Japan and SKorea to their own devices?(nm) - hefeweizen MU - 4/14 09:20:05
                                                                                               Not in those terms, but yes. Japanese and South Koreans - ummmm MU - 4/14 09:23:23
                                                                                                    In my hypothetical, wouldnt it be the US' business if their - hefeweizen MU - 4/14 09:31:13
                                                                                                         But as people have pointed out about 20 times in this thread - ummmm MU - 4/14 09:35:55
                                                                                                              ok. That response just seems to contradict what some here - hefeweizen MU - 4/14 09:39:34
                                                                                                                   No it doesn't. How???? (nm) - pickle MU - 4/14 09:54:06
                                   "If NKorea attacks Japan or SKorea..." - pickle MU - 4/14 08:50:47
                                        why did you stop quoting the entire question? (nm) - hefeweizen MU - 4/14 08:52:13
                                             Because that was enough to show you're wrong - pickle MU - 4/14 08:59:04
                                                  huh? Does the US have bases, personel, planes, ships - hefeweizen MU - 4/14 09:05:20
                                                       What do you mean"huh"? Yes, it does. (nm) - pickle MU - 4/14 09:11:26
                                                            lol, why do you do this instead of just answering the - hefeweizen MU - 4/14 09:17:54
                                                                 I've directly answered every one of your questions - pickle MU - 4/14 09:25:16
                                                                      you are being an a**hole on purpose. why? I have - hefeweizen MU - 4/14 09:33:51
                                                                           You have got to be kidding me - pickle MU - 4/14 09:42:28
                                                                                by purposely ignoring all of my question(nm) - hefeweizen MU - 4/14 09:45:46
                                                                                     I haven't ignored it. You asked a question and I answered it - pickle MU - 4/14 09:51:16
     Nothing. - ummmm MU - 4/14 08:23:58
     In other words - El-ahrairah KC - 4/14 08:20:13
          That's not an answer to my question. How is this so - hefeweizen MU - 4/14 08:21:34
               It's not. You're the one making it difficult - pickle MU - 4/14 08:47:18
                    no, my question was very simple. His answer was to withdraw - hefeweizen MU - 4/14 08:48:54
                         no, his answer was to withdraw period(nm) - MizzouAstro MU - 4/14 08:57:08
                              This isnt back to the future. My OP was very clear. The - hefeweizen MU - 4/14 09:10:52
                                   So was his answer (nm) - pickle MU - 4/14 09:39:54
                                        no. His answer was to go back in time and close - hefeweizen MU - 4/14 09:41:07
                                             No it wasn't (nm) - pickle MU - 4/14 09:51:45
                                   your OP was completely different than what you are trying - MizzouAstro MU - 4/14 09:23:58
                                        Nope. The OP is very clear to anyone with any sense. It puts - hefeweizen MU - 4/14 09:36:45
                                             None of that has happened, Reino (nm) - pickle MU - 4/14 09:52:56
               TAKE THE TROOPS OUT OF THERE YOU FOOL. - GA Tiger MU - 4/14 08:26:43
                    If they are attacked just remove troops? no response? That - hefeweizen MU - 4/14 08:37:18
                         I'm assuming our troops wouldn't be directly attacked. But - GA Tiger MU - 4/14 08:38:48
                              My OP clearly states that they would have been attacked. - hefeweizen MU - 4/14 08:45:42
     RE: Question for libs and pickle. If NKorea attacks Japan or - sarasotatiger MU - 4/14 08:19:38
          Get the hell out and let China deal with it. How on earth - GA Tiger MU - 4/14 08:30:15
     We should have had our troops out of there decades ago. - GA Tiger MU - 4/14 08:18:37
          Our troops are the reason that there has been no conflict, - hokie VT - 4/14 08:23:57
               I need an explanation. Ignoring our monumental costs - GA Tiger MU - 4/14 08:28:42
                    Maybe nothing. If we sit as dumb spectators and watch - hokie VT - 4/14 08:46:42
                         All you did was ask questions. Give me substance - GA Tiger MU - 4/14 09:16:18
                              No need to get snarky. This is a serious issue - hokie VT - 4/14 09:25:03
          That's a very stupid answer since it doesnt answer - hefeweizen MU - 4/14 08:19:59
               I realize that. But since you bring it up, why - GA Tiger MU - 4/14 08:24:14
                    What happened when our pansy in chief pulled out of - hokie VT - 4/14 09:21:44
                    Our bases shouldve been closed decades ago but they are - hefeweizen MU - 4/14 08:51:33




©2024 Fanboards L.L.C. — Our Privacy Policy   About Tigerboard