Welcome Guest
Sign In | Register

I'll start by saying that like most calls that are

Posted on: August 29, 2023 at 11:06:37 CT
GA Tiger MU
Posts:
250815
Member For:
25.32 yrs
Level:
User
M.O.B. Votes:
0
made or not made, its often not 100% clearcut and this call is one of the hardest to make. (Also, some of them will be in effect almost exactly a 50/50 situation.) First the defender cannot step too soon in front of a dribbler without giving him time to change course. But assuming he is in position in time, by the refs opinion, and the D does not change steps OR does not lean sideways into the dribbler, and if the dribbler hits him rather solidly, it would constitute a charge. IMO. If the D is set but the contact is minimal, in today's game it should be left uncalled on either side. IMO. Contact is far more than it was years ago, its constant and unavoidable given today's game.

As to bad, or terrible, calls I've often seen the D in place, hands straight up, no movement, he's slammed, maybe knocked down, AND IT'S A GODDAM BLOCK.

Thats why I'd like a replay monitor. Enough bad calls like that and the ref should lose pay. Or be fired.
Report Message

Please explain why this message is being reported.

REPLY

Handle:
Password:
Subject:

MESSAGE THREAD

Which on-court rule change should come next to men's college - wu-tangtiger MU - 8/28 17:41:00
     I would make it legal to take up to 5 steps - JG A - 8/29 14:49:23
     Timeline on past rule changes to the college game: - FIJItiger MU - 8/29 11:47:07
          Really a different game when it started and for years - GA Tiger MU - 8/29 16:48:08
               RE: Really a different game when it started and for years - Ragarm MU - 8/30 08:28:26
     I'd vote to change replay. They're making the game hard to - sprintcar STL - 8/29 11:32:35
          The NBA gives coaches 1 replay challenge - wu-tangtiger MU - 8/29 11:43:46
               Agree with all that. Make it happen....(nm) - sprintcar STL - 8/29 11:45:33
     Replay Change - BBTiger MU - 8/29 10:24:03
     i don't like the ball advancing or the flop technical deal - TigerA MU - 8/29 10:02:08
          The flop call is the stupiest thing to come in a long time. - sprintcar STL - 8/29 11:44:14
     Return to 35 sec shot clock, move 3 point line back (nm) - FIJItiger MU - 8/29 09:16:34
          35 second would get back to coaching and better team play - Central IL Tiger MU - 8/29 20:08:21
               Disagree that a 30 second shot clock - wu-tangtiger MU - 8/30 08:58:16
          back to the old location or back further from the goal?(nm) - SuperTone MU - 8/29 09:55:04
               He's trolling and doesn't watch or follow basketball (nm) - zoomer KSU - 8/29 10:31:15
               Further, to where only actual good shooters would be - FIJItiger MU - 8/29 10:26:51
                    the time is coming to widen the court. it would be good.(nm) - SuperTone MU - 8/29 10:46:51
                         How wide do you want the court? (nm) - wu-tangtiger MU - 8/29 10:49:55
                              So that Vandy's court becomes a real hazard (nm) - FIJItiger MU - 8/29 11:16:54
                              wide enough to not impede keeping the 3pt arc radius - SuperTone MU - 8/29 10:58:23
     Remove Replays(nm) - WrightWing MU - 8/29 09:02:28
          The college execution of replays is really bad - wu-tangtiger MU - 8/29 09:11:33
               Ruins the Flow of the Game(nm) - WrightWing MU - 8/29 09:50:39
     Rules changes: - o'lineydisciple MU - 8/29 08:39:10
          On 2 would you be willing to go with the G League rule - wu-tangtiger MU - 8/29 08:57:45
               That's weird - o'lineydisciple MU - 8/29 10:45:38
                    It speeds up gameplay - wu-tangtiger MU - 8/29 10:51:47
                         But how would we survive without those 15 mins of - sprintcar STL - 8/29 13:00:13
                              The one TV change I'd make - o'lineydisciple MU - 8/29 13:25:56
     Easy - bagpipertiger MU - 8/29 08:27:41
     My two, in order: - GA Tiger MU - 8/29 06:50:29
          Mr Official.. can you define the block charge for the rest - MizzouGunner MU - 8/29 07:24:56
               I'll start by saying that like most calls that are - GA Tiger MU - 8/29 11:06:37
               That's easy. - tgr MU - 8/29 07:32:03
                    funny...lol nm - MizzouGunner MU - 8/29 10:52:56
                    ^^^gets it(nm) - TigerA MU - 8/29 10:06:46
               Here we go - alwaysright MU - 8/29 07:27:53
     I’d be fine with advancing the ball - MidMoBaller4Life MU - 8/28 22:27:42
          There are a lot of FIBA rules that I think college should - wu-tangtiger MU - 8/29 09:10:01
          advancing the ball is a horrible rule. It’s BS, failed, - alwaysright MU - 8/29 07:24:16
               That’s your opinion - MidMoBaller4Life MU - 8/29 08:13:33
                    Makes the end easier - alwaysright MU - 8/29 08:29:49
               Why? (nm) - wu-tangtiger MU - 8/29 07:26:48
                    Why should they get a free pass? - alwaysright MU - 8/29 07:52:07
                         There aren’t any free passes in hoops - wu-tangtiger MU - 8/29 08:01:55
                              But don’t have to face full court pressure and are - alwaysright MU - 8/29 08:17:05
                                   Most teams don’t go with full court pressure (nm) - wu-tangtiger MU - 8/29 08:54:55
     RE: Which on-court rule change should come next to men's college - KC rules MU - 8/28 21:26:39
          It strongly affects the FT bonus on games - MIZtigerZOU MU - 8/29 09:37:21
          Quarters could do a couple things - wu-tangtiger MU - 8/28 22:29:07
               I'm all for quarters for those reasons. And have I said - sprintcar STL - 8/29 11:41:46
                    College basketball could be smart to really look - wu-tangtiger MU - 8/29 11:47:03
                         Yes please. I know we're not going to get rid of TV timeouts - sprintcar STL - 8/29 12:54:42
                              there are ways to implement tv advertising - wu-tangtiger MU - 8/29 13:11:09
     Move the 3 pt line back to 35 feet - force the players to - alstl MU - 8/28 20:54:23
          I see no value to that. Like, hitting just a 32 footer - GA Tiger MU - 8/29 06:52:43
               It's 22 feet now - the value would be increasing skill level - alstl MU - 8/29 07:48:05
     I'd like to see 3 free throws awarded to a team trailing by - CoolBreeze22 MU - 8/28 19:54:08
          RE: I'd like to see 3 free throws awarded to a team trailing by - THEGROVE68 MU - 8/29 06:39:36
          That's not a bad idea - KC rules MU - 8/28 21:30:27
               On that issue, here's what should change: - GA Tiger MU - 8/29 06:56:39
     The people making the rules have no idea how - alwaysright MU - 8/28 19:40:06
          Maybe one reason is that, regarding reffing, - GA Tiger MU - 8/29 06:58:39
          Have they? - wu-tangtiger MU - 8/28 20:38:50
               double bonus failed. "less contact" ruined the game because - alwaysright MU - 8/29 06:51:46
               well, it's 30 years later and you're still asking this - 90Tiger STL - 8/28 20:56:35
                    So no answers that are better - wu-tangtiger MU - 8/28 21:46:45
                         RE: So no answers that are better - THEGROVE68 MU - 8/29 06:48:01
                              You mean well...but misguided IMO. With not - GA Tiger MU - 8/29 07:01:20




©2024 Fanboards L.L.C. — Our Privacy Policy   About Tigerboard