Welcome Guest
Sign In | Register

He seems to have had some contradicting ideas

Posted on: September 29, 2022 at 12:50:44 CT
cnk ATL
Posts:
188521
Member For:
25.66 yrs
Level:
User
M.O.B. Votes:
0
but his rationalization seems to be in the first paragraph you cited:

In the same document, Proudhon also described the "form of government" he was proposing as "a centralization analogous with that of the State, but in which no one obeys, no one is dependent, and everyone is free and sovereign"


And mutualism was his blending of anarchy and socialism. I'm not sure that means he couldn't decide what which one he was.
Report Message

Please explain why this message is being reported.

REPLY

Handle:
Password:
Subject:

MESSAGE THREAD

To be GOVERNED is to be watched, inspected, spied upon, - pickle MU - 9/29 11:48:57
     RE: To be GOVERNED is to be watched, inspected, spied upon, - Wildcat KSU - 9/29 13:13:03
     So claims a French Anti-Semite who couldn't - Spanky KU - 9/29 12:01:19
          He was both - cnk ATL - 9/29 12:16:22
               So he was in support of forced association of ownership - MizzouTigerz MU - 9/29 12:51:04
                    probably, he was anti-capitalist and against private - cnk ATL - 9/29 12:52:46
               RE: He was both - jonesin - 9/29 12:25:49
                    I have(nm) - cnk ATL - 9/29 12:51:22
                         Have you looked at the end of the Barn lately? - jonesin - 9/29 12:52:27
                              no(nm) - cnk ATL - 9/29 12:53:48
               Anarchist by self claim only - Spanky KU - 9/29 12:24:03
                    Lol, got ‘em!(nm) - tigerNkc KC - 9/29 13:52:27
                         if by avoiding the topic and content - pickle MU - 9/29 14:07:33
                              Got em!(nm) - tigerNkc KC - 9/29 19:21:54
                    you don’t understand a thing about anarchism (nm) - pickle MU - 9/29 12:51:58
                         anarchism is the belief in the abolition of all government(nm) - Spanky KU - 9/29 12:58:01
                    He seems to have had some contradicting ideas - cnk ATL - 9/29 12:50:44
                         Anarchism is the absence of government - Spanky KU - 9/29 12:55:58
                              the key to the form of government he advocated - cnk ATL - 9/29 13:23:10
                                   He advocated a strong central gummint - Spanky KU - 9/29 13:28:05
                                        are you saying mutualism is only socialism and not - cnk ATL - 9/29 13:48:12
                                             I am saying a strong central gummint is not - Spanky KU - 9/29 14:02:33
                                                  I don't think he advocated for strong central government - cnk ATL - 9/29 14:28:50
                                                       Proudhon argued for increasing the powers of government - Spanky KU - 9/29 14:46:15
                              no (nm) - pickle MU - 9/29 13:11:26
                                   Yes. it is.(nm) - Spanky KU - 9/29 13:20:42
                              Sounds like Neil Young... - jonesin - 9/29 12:57:21
     If only there was a no govt utopia! - RHAYWORTH MU - 9/29 11:56:57
          that’s a straw man - pickle MU - 9/29 12:03:07
     What "revolution" in the 19th century? Not that I totally - jonesin - 9/29 11:54:00
          RE: What "revolution" in the 19th century? Not that I totally - SwampTiger MU - 9/29 12:03:25
               I got it now. I was looking for an actual kinetic action - jonesin - 9/29 12:11:47
          RE: What "revolution" in the 19th century? Not that I totally - JayHoaxH8r MU - 9/29 11:55:27
               You mean my bell bottoms and perm were a "revolution" in - jonesin - 9/29 11:59:19
                    no - JayHoaxH8r MU - 9/29 12:01:06
                         Lol...The 90's? - jonesin - 9/29 12:13:20




©2024 Fanboards L.L.C. — Our Privacy Policy   About Tigerboard