Welcome Guest
Sign In | Register

fair assessment

Posted on: September 16, 2019 at 15:30:57 CT
meatiger MU
Posts:
123270
Member For:
25.31 yrs
Level:
User
M.O.B. Votes:
0
I can see two types of QBs

Those like Brady and Eli playing forever because athletic training is so much better to allow for longevity

Those like Luck that make their money and get out to have a good lifestyle, especially with the risks that NFL brings..even with the QB protection standards.

Either way, Eli has had a very good career worthy of HOF....GOAT...not even close...but solid....2 rings makes it completely solid.
Report Message

Please explain why this message is being reported.

REPLY

Handle:
Password:
Subject:

MESSAGE THREAD

Is Eli a HOF QB? Looks like he's about done.Has 2 rings but. - Macgrantt MU - 9/16 14:45:42
     2 rings and top 10 in yards. First ballot - Eggs MU - 9/16 15:34:23
          His last name being Manning doesn't hurt either (nm) - Cosmo MU - 9/16 15:44:51
               didn't help Cooper(nm) - TigerA MU - 9/16 15:45:43
                    Talk about a black sheep, two brothers and dad are all - Cosmo MU - 9/16 15:49:57
                         Cooper had a spinal problem that ended his football career*(nm) - bcoop199 KC - 9/16 18:38:36
                         he makes more than both his brothers combined. - phrejd MU - 9/16 15:53:25
                              He got in early investing in the St Louis Battlehawks - Cosmo MU - 9/16 15:55:00
                    Kupp?(nm) - Eggs MU - 9/16 15:48:58
                    i think cooper is doing just fine (nm) - phrejd MU - 9/16 15:47:05
                         Amari?(nm) - Eggs MU - 9/16 15:49:26
                              Stoudemire? (nm) - Cosmo MU - 9/16 15:50:19
                         it was either him or Rex so i went cooper(nm) - TigerA MU - 9/16 15:48:27
               Yup. And the 2 SB rings were over Brady/Belichick(nm) - Eggs MU - 9/16 15:45:37
                    I'm just trying to figure out what I'd like his bust to be - Cosmo MU - 9/16 15:48:57
     Yes, he's in (nm) - MrBlueSky MU - 9/16 15:03:18
     Barely - tbluck MU - 9/16 14:56:30
          Who passes him? - meatiger MU - 9/16 15:04:12
               Rivers, Rodgers, Ryan, Stafford(nm) - tbluck MU - 9/16 15:09:15
                    RE: Rivers, Rodgers, Ryan, Stafford(nm) - meatiger MU - 9/16 15:12:51
                         Operating under a couple premises - tbluck MU - 9/16 15:23:10
                              fair assessment - meatiger MU - 9/16 15:30:57
                                   Agreed. Stafford will be an interesting one down the road - tbluck MU - 9/16 15:35:41
                                        Marino was slinging it around before the game was played - Eggs MU - 9/16 15:39:47
                                             No doubt, just talking pure numbers(nm) - tbluck MU - 9/16 15:47:12
                                        Marino's an interesting comparison - Mormad MU - 9/16 15:38:05
                                             Detroit is just bad - meatiger MU - 9/16 15:47:17
                                             True, Rivers may be the better comparison - tbluck MU - 9/16 15:42:24
                                                  I think they're both better QBs - Mormad MU - 9/16 15:51:30
     No. He was not ever really all that good (nm) - FIJItiger MU - 9/16 14:51:38
          56,000 yards (7th all time) with 2 super bowls. Um yeah, he - tigerNkc KC - 9/16 14:56:47
               He will move in to 6th all time passsing big Ben on probably - TheWildcat STL - 9/16 14:57:32
          His numbers aren't much different than Big Ben (nm) - TheWildcat STL - 9/16 14:53:46
               More seasons than not he was a below avg QB - FIJItiger MU - 9/16 14:55:22
                    His yards per year was very consistent - meatiger MU - 9/16 15:00:48
                         Lets put it this way - FIJItiger MU - 9/16 15:04:29
                              remember this the next time you call Donald Trump an - 90Tiger STL - 9/16 19:44:17
                              you may want to stick to "where are they now" posts on the - phrejd MU - 9/16 15:46:23
                                   I can multitask and do both (nm) - FIJItiger MU - 9/16 15:52:41
                                        clearly you can not (nm) - phrejd MU - 9/16 15:53:55
                              RE: Lets put it this way - cnk ATL - 9/16 15:07:38
                              I agree with this but I still say he gets in (nm) - lqf2b8 MU - 9/16 15:06:54
                              Eli had a much better career and numbers than AS (nm) - TheWildcat STL - 9/16 15:06:47
                                   But he wasn't a better QB and didn't give you - FIJItiger MU - 9/16 15:08:04
                              Let's put it this way - meatiger MU - 9/16 15:05:51
                                   That isn't a fact, nor meant to be (nm) - FIJItiger MU - 9/16 15:07:14
                                   he is good at facts - TigerA MU - 9/16 15:06:37
                                        He is wrong on both accounts this time(nm) - meatiger MU - 9/16 15:07:13
     sure why not (nm) - Sal CMSU - 9/16 14:51:30
     7th all time in passing yards. He will be in (nm) - TheWildcat STL - 9/16 14:50:50
          yep - meatiger MU - 9/16 14:57:27
               also 16th in per game yards - meatiger MU - 9/16 14:59:35
          Longevity? Wonder how many in modern era played QB 16 years - Macgrantt MU - 9/16 14:55:35
     seems like he is a level below HoF. Owned the Pats in the - TigerA MU - 9/16 14:47:11
          also a good SNL host(nm) - TigerA MU - 9/16 14:52:06




©2024 Fanboards L.L.C. — Our Privacy Policy   About Tigerboard