Welcome Guest
Sign In | Register

Schmidt had the defensive edge on Brett for sure

Posted on: May 14, 2019 at 16:06:07 CT
Joeboo MU
Posts:
158288
Member For:
21.49 yrs
Level:
User
M.O.B. Votes:
0
Brett was just an average defender, Schmidt decidely above average.

Offensively, they're about a wash. Brett hit for better average, Schmidt more power. Both pretty close in offensive WAR for their careers
Report Message

Please explain why this message is being reported.

REPLY

Handle:
Password:
Subject:

MESSAGE THREAD

All time best third baseman? - alstl MU - 5/14 15:53:23
     Chone Figgins. Dude could do everything. (nm) - HandBanana MU - 5/15 00:04:56
     1) Schmidt 2) Brett 3) Mathews(nm) - Zamboni STL - 5/14 22:46:34
     Brooks Robinson - Mormad MU - 5/14 22:27:08
          Robinson sucked at hitting(nm) - tigerNkc KC - 5/15 07:24:48
     Matt Carpenter - gmmm98 MU - 5/14 20:08:40
     Scott Rolen. - KCT-BoneTiger A - 5/14 19:34:39
          top 7; career too short; shoulder injuries killed him (nm) - 90Tiger STL - 5/14 19:43:02
               He is dead? - meatiger MU - 5/14 20:09:35
               His career WAR of 70.2 - KCT-BoneTiger A - 5/14 19:46:25
                    ok so top 9 (nm) - 90Tiger STL - 5/14 20:23:28
                         so, he should be in HOF? (nm) - KCT-BoneTiger A - 5/14 21:02:17
          RE: Scott Rolen. - KCT-BoneTiger A - 5/14 19:36:39
     Pete Rose(nm) - jumbo73 MU - 5/14 19:21:30
          He played like 5 positions and got his only Gold Gloves - Diamond Dave MU - 5/14 19:31:54
               3B was one of those positions(nm) - jumbo73 MU - 5/14 20:33:18
     Brett and Schmidt two best I ever saw - mu7176grad MU - 5/14 19:17:38
          Royals fan and love the pre-marrying-a-Beaker-Ho - Diamond Dave MU - 5/14 19:32:55
     Wade Boggs?(nm) - meatiger MU - 5/14 18:52:24
          too little power for the position, not a great defender at a - 90Tiger STL - 5/14 19:18:36
          Great hitter - not as much power as some others - alstl MU - 5/14 18:57:30
               He could outdrink them all though(nm) - playhard KC - 5/14 19:01:57
               To sone extent power is over rated - meatiger MU - 5/14 19:01:27
                    Too much money on the line for those types of players - Diamond Dave MU - 5/14 19:37:33
                         i do too. (nm) - 90Tiger STL - 5/14 20:25:09
                    the days of players who are quite possibly utterly unique? - 90Tiger STL - 5/14 19:10:40
     Brooks Robinson(nm) - Erwin Fletcher STL - 5/14 18:36:39
     interesting that there are so few third basemen - Doc Stone MU - 5/14 16:49:24
          catchers. Ted Simmons belongs in the HoF (nm) - 90Tiger STL - 5/14 19:16:49
               RE: catchers. Ted Simmons belongs in the HoF (nm) - scan MU - 5/14 19:21:45
          Some of them like Killebrew don't spend the entire career - alstl MU - 5/14 17:41:21
     surprised no ones mentioned Edwin Encarnacion - HA nm - showme NWMSU - 5/14 16:48:51
          Too tough to spell(nm) - meatiger MU - 5/14 19:07:44
     Pulley. (nm) - McMuffin MU - 5/14 16:29:03
     Chipper Jones might be an under the radar guy(nm) - playhard KC - 5/14 16:24:21
          Played all over the place which hurts him otherwise yes he - Erwin Fletcher STL - 5/14 18:37:42
          that's because he wasn't as good as the guys already named(nm) - TigerA MU - 5/14 16:25:23
               Better career than Brooks(nm) - playhard KC - 5/14 16:27:19
                    Brooks played 23 years for the same team! nm - showme NWMSU - 5/14 16:34:04
                         wth does being with the same team have to do with - 90Tiger STL - 5/14 19:17:37
                    not with the glove(nm) - Doc Stone MU - 5/14 16:28:59
                         Blows him away at the plate, his offensive numbers are - playhard KC - 5/14 16:30:27
                              Never said he didn't. - Doc Stone MU - 5/14 16:48:46
     Schmidt, then Brett (nm) - sYsTiger MU - 5/14 16:21:17
     I think it should be someone who came up as a 3rd - playhard KC - 5/14 16:21:16
     Schmidt... - Gyro MU - 5/14 16:16:57
     Brooks Robinson is up there.(nm) - Fool on the Hill MU - 5/14 16:13:13
     Brooks Robinson; Cal Ripken nm - showme NWMSU - 5/14 16:13:02
          Scott Rolen of course. (nm) - Lt. J. Dangle MU - 5/14 16:34:45
          Ripken is primarily a SS (nm) - TheWildcat STL - 5/14 16:19:47
     chris owings. End of debate. Thats how you - SabertoothTiger MU - 5/14 16:06:11
     either ken oberkfell or terry pendleton (nm) - SwampTiger MU - 5/14 15:59:09
          Both lag behind Fernando Tatis(nm) - doughboy MU - 5/14 16:49:40
               only in the big ears category (nm) - SwampTiger MU - 5/14 17:00:05
          add ken reitz if we're doing top 3 (nm) - SwampTiger MU - 5/14 16:04:59
               Who was that Sugarbear dude? (nm) - Newcatbirdseat MU - 5/14 16:05:42
                    Floyd Rayford. - Newcatbirdseat MU - 5/14 16:07:12
                         traded for Tito Landrum, had to be an incredible player - SwampTiger MU - 5/14 16:34:21
     most people say schmidt.(nm) - SabertoothTiger MU - 5/14 15:56:50
          defintely but ARod is in the conversation (nm) - pickle MU - 5/14 16:07:26
               No roid boys - and Arod was a SS for a long time(nm) - alstl MU - 5/14 17:20:38
               Had he played 3rd his whole career he would be the no - TheWildcat STL - 5/14 16:15:48
               I didn't realize he played 10 years at 3rd. About half of - SabertoothTiger MU - 5/14 16:10:27
          He is without a doubt #1 (nm) - TheWildcat STL - 5/14 16:00:17
               Schmidt had the defensive edge on Brett for sure - Joeboo MU - 5/14 16:06:07
                    2nd best alltime is pretty well above average. Schmidt - 90Tiger STL - 5/14 18:44:25
     I'd take Jones over Mathews (nm) - TheWildcat STL - 5/14 15:56:15
          Jones is legit but Mathews played his entire career vs - alstl MU - 5/14 17:18:57




©2025 Fanboards L.L.C. — Our Privacy Policy   About Tigerboard