Welcome Guest
Sign In | Register

Rankings of Pinkel-era, BO-era, and current QBs

Posted on: May 26, 2020 at 15:01:50 CT
Diamond Dave MU
Posts:
80530
Member For:
25.24 yrs
Level:
User
M.O.B. Votes:
0
Per 247 (and couldn't find any info. on Brad Smith, but he wasn't very highly regarded at all):

Gabbert - .9806
Lock - .9553
Robinson - .9222
Franklin - .9065
Mauk - .9031
Bazelak - .8913
Daniel and Bryant- .8777

Powell wasn't included. Although he's taken snaps, has never been a threat to win out over others. Commit Tyler Macon is slightly above Powell in rankings. Both below Daniel and Bryant.

I'm usually negatively outspoken about star rankings, but I think you can fairly accurately rank QBs versus just about any other position.

Daniel was really the only one who outplayed his ranking. I'd say everyone else played pretty close to the production anticipated by their ranking. I'd also say no one underplayed their ranking. Gabbert ended up a first-rounder; Lock a second-rounder. Franklin is still on a CFL roster, but mostly used as a short-yardage running QB, his strength here. Mauk was obviously derailed by personal issues. Performance-wise though, in college, I'd say Mauk played to his ranking.

Assuming Robinson's the starter game one, it'd sure be nice to not have him underplay his ranking and if he's between Lock and Franklin, we have a very solid QB. Jury's still out on Bazelak b/c not known if the knee will be ready.

Brady Cook would be below Daniel and Bryant but not included as he's 4th on the depth chart currently.

Edited by Diamond Dave at 16:18:03 on 05/26/20
Report Message

Please explain why this message is being reported.

REPLY

Handle:
Password:
Subject:

MESSAGE THREAD

Rankings of Pinkel-era, BO-era, and current QBs - Diamond Dave MU - 5/26 15:01:50
     So odd that our two most iconic QBs - STRIPES - 5/27 06:53:47
          Would anyone take Smith over Franklin? No way. - ToTheFinishLine MU - 5/27 10:45:48
               Kind of depends here. When Franklin was healthy and - alwaysright MU - 5/28 17:02:54
               You'd take Mauk over Brad Smith? - Cosmo MU - 5/27 11:55:07
                    That is laughable (nm) - samclemens MU - 5/27 15:42:41
               He changed our program. Have respect.Great college QB(nm) - TigerFan92 MU - 5/27 11:00:21
                    Brad never averaged higher than 6.5 yards per attempt in - Diamond Dave MU - 5/27 12:22:52
                         Brad was an athlete that we played at QB because we needed - Erwin Fletcher STL - 5/27 17:05:57
                    He was fine. But out of all of the QBs we have had, - ToTheFinishLine MU - 5/27 11:38:37
          Identifying and developing QB's was Pinkel's genius - samclemens MU - 5/27 07:04:04
               He did that going back to his UW and Toledo days - Diamond Dave MU - 5/27 10:19:10
     What is Baselak's #? NM - ColoradoBlueTiger MU - 5/26 20:29:58
          .8913, 4-star, with a Georgia offer(nm) - Diamond Dave MU - 5/27 09:35:30
          You want to call him? - SoFlaTiger MU - 5/27 03:07:03
               Just text him see whats up. - ColoradoBlueTiger MU - 5/27 09:43:52
     FWIW Corbin Berkstresser was .8599.(nm) - BigTime SEMO - 5/26 17:56:09
          I purposely left him off, because I really only went with - Diamond Dave MU - 5/26 17:59:25
     If Robinson plays anywhere near in between Franklin and Lock - mzu-fan MU - 5/26 17:11:02
          Take for what it's worth, but Christian Holmes said in his - Diamond Dave MU - 5/26 17:53:18
               Surprised by how little confidence our fans - samclemens MU - 5/27 07:59:22
                    I think most are being cautious not pessimistic - MoGold MU - 5/27 10:26:02
     I just hope Drink doesn't hesitate to pull - HDTiger MU - 5/26 15:21:31
          If Drinkwitz stands by someone - Guinny_Ire MU - 5/26 17:03:55
               Also, he didn’t recruit Robinson, so he doesn’t ‘owe’ him - MoGold MU - 5/27 10:33:35
               I agree with your assertion Odom didn't want to jeopardize - SoFlaTiger MU - 5/27 04:35:36
                    The very fact he was injured was my biggest issue with Odom - MoGold MU - 5/27 10:37:19
               Odom really had no choice on Bryant as I posted below - Diamond Dave MU - 5/26 17:57:33
                    RE: Odom really had no choice on Bryant as I posted below - justwinbaby KC - 5/27 09:27:59
               I think Odom just thought Bryant was good - Genco98 MU - 5/26 17:44:13
                    Probably more a call by Dooley. On the surface, I'd - BigTime SEMO - 5/26 18:10:14
          More to that BO thing, IMO. Bazelak was a true FR - Diamond Dave MU - 5/26 15:32:24
               I just believe that after KB got banged up so badly - HDTiger MU - 5/26 21:36:00
               RE: Bazelak: did he burn his shirt or still eligible? - dewey9 SMS - 5/26 16:49:31
                    Only played in 3 games, so he's fine. Even if he played - Diamond Dave MU - 5/26 17:51:18
               I think that they saw that - STRIPES - 5/26 16:06:59
                    Probably for the best at this juncture. Didn't burn a year - Diamond Dave MU - 5/26 16:16:34
     That's a very interesting breakdown - STRIPES - 5/26 15:20:20
          You're very welcome. I had forgotten that Bazelak was - Diamond Dave MU - 5/26 15:23:49
               Brad outplayed his ranking as well - BigDave MU - 5/26 15:50:36
                    Very much so, but ultimately didn't play QB at the next - Diamond Dave MU - 5/26 16:02:37
                         He was in many ways ahead of his time - MoGold MU - 5/27 10:29:39




©2024 Fanboards L.L.C. — Our Privacy Policy   About Tigerboard