Welcome Guest
Sign In | Register

RE: This Georgia fan makes a good argument in this post

Posted on: June 3, 2012 at 10:29:28 CT
meansonny UGA
Posts:
691
Member For:
1.18 yrs
Level:
User
M.O.B. Votes:
0
A selection committee isn't going to choose based upon OOC schedules.

This is the way football has been done ever since it started. And it will be the way football is done even with conference champions only (because there are more than 4 conferences).
A committee or poll will rank the teams based upon the entire schedule (in conference and out). But you are going to lessen the desire for teams to schedule big OOC games like Alabama (who did a home and home with Penn St), LSU (who played 2 tough AQ teams last season), or UGA (who has probably scheduled as hard a OOC as any team in the country the last 10 seasons).
Those OOC games can hurt a teams chances to win their division and conference (UGA lost Alec Ogletree for 4+ games when he got injured against Boise). He's our most athletic linebacker and actually has the highest upside if he could just stay on the field. 3rd most solo tackles at ILB despite missing 4+ games)
Report Message

Please explain why this message is being reported.

REPLY

Handle:
Password:
Subject:

MESSAGE THREAD

This Georgia fan makes a good argument in this post - MakeShift MU - 6/3 09:20:48
     I think he's right - AndyTiger MU - 6/3 11:33:56
          Playing one of those teams with the rest of that schedule - MakeShift MU - 6/3 14:37:58
     RE: This Georgia fan makes a good argument in this post - meansonny UGA - 6/3 10:29:28
     Conference champions only will solve that problem(nm) - alstl MU - 6/3 09:56:02
          No it won't - Bobk MU - 6/3 11:29:54
               What IS meaningful to you Bob? - MakeShift MU - 6/3 18:17:17
                    I don't think anyone should think about the tournament and - BadAsh SEC - 6/3 19:37:49
               you talk about conference issues, not issues - SuperTone MU - 6/3 15:41:20
                    NCAA shouldn't have anything to do with it. - BadAsh SEC - 6/3 19:39:12
          RE: Conference champions only will solve that problem(nm) - meansonny UGA - 6/3 10:15:48
               Oh and speaking of butthurt, William Tecumseh Sherman ... - alstl MU - 6/3 12:08:57
                    RE: Oh and speaking of butthurt, William Tecumseh Sherman ... - DawgHolliday UGA - 6/3 12:21:06
                         My great grandfather from Indiana was in Sherman's army.... - alstl MU - 6/3 15:39:45
               It's not that complicated... - alstl MU - 6/3 10:59:44
                    That's assuming all conference are equal, which they aren't - Mizzmi27 MU - 6/3 12:14:19
                    How dumb can you get? - tigerboardnoob MU - 6/3 12:10:45
                    RE: It's not that complicated... - meansonny UGA - 6/3 11:13:10
                         Because then it gets political, subjective and corrupt - alstl MU - 6/3 11:30:03
                              RE: Because then it gets political, subjective and corrupt - meansonny UGA - 6/3 11:35:34
                                   Since Missouri and LSU were both 12-2 in 2007... - alstl MU - 6/3 12:23:10
                                        RE: Since Missouri and LSU were both 12-2 in 2007... - DawgHolliday UGA - 6/3 12:40:56
                                   RE: Because then it gets political, subjective and corrupt - DawgHolliday UGA - 6/3 11:36:43
                                        Lol! Hey welcome over here. I'll "be your huckleberry" Dawgs - jonesin - 6/3 12:19:50
                                             RE: Lol! Hey welcome over here. I'll "be your huckleberry" Dawgs - DawgHolliday UGA - 6/3 12:52:25
                              Who are you, Jim Delaney? - Bobk MU - 6/3 11:32:20
                         RE: It's not that complicated... - DawgHolliday UGA - 6/3 11:22:28
                              RE: It's not that complicated... - meansonny UGA - 6/3 11:26:56
                                   RE: It's not that complicated... - DawgHolliday UGA - 6/3 11:30:28
                                        RE: It's not that complicated... - meansonny UGA - 6/3 11:36:28
                    no it isn't.. - CalicoTiger MU - 6/3 11:03:53
                         RE: no it isn't.. - meansonny UGA - 6/3 11:15:05
                              RE: no it isn't.. - CalicoTiger MU - 6/3 11:50:36
                              Not a troll, been around forever. Just not that bright. He - ZouFaninD MU - 6/3 11:48:02
               RE: Conference champions only will solve that problem(nm) - meansonny UGA - 6/3 10:18:10
          Right . . . because, as we all know all the conferences - hangman MU - 6/3 10:01:10
               exactly. No one knows which "conference" is truly - SuperTone MU - 6/3 10:21:35
                    I asked you earlier, never answered, here it goes again - Mizzmi27 MU - 6/3 12:10:57
                         Why does it? Create 8 ten team conferences... - SuperTone MU - 6/3 15:36:08
                              Because we are talking about reality and not some made up - Mizzmi27 MU - 6/3 15:52:52
                    Best in the country over the entire season? - Bobk MU - 6/3 11:49:30
                         Over the season. You can't be in it if you don't win - SuperTone MU - 6/3 15:40:13
                              RE: Over the season. You can't be in it if you don't win - meansonny UGA - 6/3 16:23:32
                    You don't think Alabama was the best team last year? - ZouFaninD MU - 6/3 10:27:01
                         LSU won @ bama and has the SEC trophy.... - SuperTone MU - 6/3 15:37:22
                         I still point to 1971 where the best 3 teams were Big 8 - Bobk MU - 6/3 12:06:48
                              the 3 best by opinion. They didn't prove it on the field.(nm) - SuperTone MU - 6/3 15:38:49
                    RE: exactly. No one knows which "conference" is truly - meansonny UGA - 6/3 10:25:09
                    the current system has the best chance of getting the - CalicoTiger MU - 6/3 10:25:07
                         based on opinion, not on the field.(nm) - SuperTone MU - 6/3 15:37:51
                         RE: the current system has the best chance of getting the - meansonny UGA - 6/3 10:32:06
                              no I wouldn't necessarily like that... - CalicoTiger MU - 6/3 10:49:02
                                   RE: no I wouldn't necessarily like that... - meansonny UGA - 6/3 11:19:20
                                        don't think it's that hard to reverse engineer - CalicoTiger MU - 6/3 11:39:39
          But his argument is to use a committee - MakeShift MU - 6/3 10:01:09
               RE: But his argument is to use a committee - meansonny UGA - 6/3 11:21:20
                    Same system as before though - MakeShift MU - 6/3 14:36:04
               A committee should be for seeding the conference champs - alstl MU - 6/3 10:50:17
                    You choosing when a committee is appropriate is completely - Mizzmi27 MU - 6/3 12:14:54
                    How are you going to keep out lower conference teams - Bobk MU - 6/3 11:55:58
                         Then what's the point of the conferences? - MakeShift MU - 6/3 18:37:34
                              RE: Then what's the point of the conferences? - DawgHolliday UGA - 6/3 20:01:29
                    RE: A committee should be for seeding the conference champs - DawgHolliday UGA - 6/3 11:28:20
                    RE: A committee should be for seeding the conference champs - meansonny UGA - 6/3 11:23:44
     hasn't the Beast been the definitive example of why - CalicoTiger MU - 6/3 09:48:17
          I guess as a Mizzou fan I'd lke to see small divisions to - MakeShift MU - 6/3 09:59:25
               neither system is perfect but in yours - CalicoTiger MU - 6/3 10:13:14
          "Beast"? - MakeShift MU - 6/3 09:51:24
               Big East, bro(nm) - JCain816 KC - 6/3 10:04:23
               Big East shortened(nm) - MizzouRules KC - 6/3 09:55:18




©2013 Fanboards L.L.C. — Our Privacy Policy   About Tigerboard